40 ms·
She is famous because she joined the right startup in the early days. She has never demonstrated that she can repeat her success after driving numerous companie
by melony 5y ago
She is famous because she joined the right startup in the early days. She has never demonstrated that she can repeat her success after driving numerous companies' valuation into the ground post-google. The media loves her because she share the same qualities as Theranos' Elizabeth Holmes. I doubt the other former senior execs at Alphabet would get the same kid glove treatment. It is the same story as Meg Whitman as they both fit the same narrative favored by the media. It is easy to be a generic exec at already successful company, especially if your first job propels you to C level. Fixing a failing company or building a new company from scratch is what distinguishes the truly excellent business people. There is a reason Jobs, Bezos, Gates, and Nadella are looked up to. They either built from scratch a successfully company, brought a failing corporation to success, or both in the case of Jobs. We don't shower praise upon Ballmer precisely because he did a bad job. It would be hypocritical to advocate gender equality by not holding the likes of Mayer and Whitman to the same standards. Just being a good manager and executive is nothing exceptional, you can find plenty to fill these sort of roles from MBA programs. (I will however admit that Yahoo's APM program is a true innovation)
- pavlov 5y agoThere are plenty of male tech executives with equally poor track records as Mayer (David Marcus comes to mind), yet they don’t get this kind of treatment on message forums. Comparing Meyer to Holmes is like comparing David Marcus to Bernie Madoff. It just doesn’t make sense unless you’re seeing someone primarily through their gender.
- jetsetgo 5y ago
- lmm 5y ago> There are plenty of male tech executives with equally poor track records as Mayer (David Marcus comes to mind), yet they don’t get this kind of treatment on message forums. If they had the same kind of media coverage they probably would. When I hear Tumblr I think of Meyer because we had dozens of articles covering that. I couldn't tell you what Marcus runs (Goldman Sachs' consumer-lending division?)
- magicalist 5y ago> She has never demonstrated that she can repeat her success after driving numerous companies' valuation into the ground post-google. Company, single. But yes, it would also be nonsensical to say Steve Ballmer excelled at failing upwards. That's not what that phrase means.