3 ms·

We already know that infection does not "generate a broader response", actually. Nor does it generate a more effective one. The opposite is the case.

• spurgu 5y ago
  We don't "know" that. It depends on what data you're looking at. CDC has two papers supporting vaccine-induced immunity, one of which was highly flawed. And then there's the study from Israel clearly supporting natural immunity.
  • Bud 5y ago
    The study from Israel has been widely debunked and has yet to be supported by anything else. It's mostly cited by Fox News as an excuse for anti-vax sentiment.
    • spurgu 5y ago
      Widely debunked? I've missed that. Care to share some papers/analyses?
      • Bud 5y ago
        https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2021/sep/01/gateway-pundit/immunity-gained-covid-19-infection-ignores-risks-g/ https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2021/sep/01/gateway-pu... No vetting of that Israeli study, no peer review, no competent efforts to account for bias in the sample, and it just does not hold up to scrutiny when compared to other results.