3 ms·
"Here though, I would argue that the forced shift in developers' mindsets, from "I want to control more things just in case" to "I want to control fewer things
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago
"Here though, I would argue that the forced shift in developers' mindsets, from "I want to control more things just in case" to "I want to control fewer things just in case", also has many positive consequences."
For the US, I think the most expedient route to this climate of fear (caution) that yields positive consequences lies not in government regulation but in removing impediments to private liability, or perhaps creating new sources of private liability. The requisite fear of liability to yield positive consequences is a threat of private litigation, not a threat of fines set by government agencies.
It is not for the government to decide how much "tech" companies should pay for their wrongdoing. It is for the victims of that wrongdoing and a jury of their peers to decide.
It is not users who have pushed us to this breaking point. it is "tech" companies and web developers.
- FridgeSeal 5y agoAh yes, it’s well known that as a single user, I totally have the power the meaningfully affect Facebook/Clearview/Google/etc when they do something to me, or with my data that I deem unacceptable. I can’t effectively sue them-they have an army of lawyers and can throw more cash without blinking than I can muster with years of work. They also have near bulletproof legal clauses. Simply deleting my account doesn’t do a lot against any of them (facebooks shadow accounts, googles pervasive ad/product network, clearview already harvesting all the data they need) and they have harvested so much, or have so many users, that the loss of a few over some principal means literally nothing to them. So yeah, I’m pretty happy for governments to regulate companies into the ground on my behalf: if they demonstrably can’t be trusted to do the right thing, then they can suffer the consequences.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago"So yeah, I'm pretty happy for governments to regulate companies into the ground on my behalf..." That is not going to happen. The government serves two masters.
- ehnto 5y agoThere is already personal liability in the US, in theory you can sue anyone for anything, but in practice that's simply not true, there are entities and people untouchable to those they affect, and that's where the government should step in. I get this feeling of fear of the unknown from US citizens talking about regulation, like your just one piece of red tape away from tyranny, but regulations have been making your country work properly since it became a country, and this is just a new frontier of decisions to make for how this stuff works in your society.