3 ms·
You’d still need backup heat production (heat pump, or wood burning, or fossil fuel, or electrical off batteries) for the inevitable month long ‘gray and cold’
by lazide 5y ago
You’d still need backup heat production (heat pump, or wood burning, or fossil fuel, or electrical off batteries) for the inevitable month long ‘gray and cold’ stretches, or you’re gonna freeze.
Single purpose but not reliably there heat capture methods add cost and maintenance.
It’s often more cost effective to have a general purpose method that while not as efficient in one case is generally more overall (cost) efficient.
- WalterBright 5y agoPassive solar heating should be very maintenance free. It's the point of it. Sure, a backup plan is a good idea. But it doesn't have to be very good or very efficient, as it will be rarely used.
- lazide 5y agoPretty sure you don’t live in Central Europe or areas like northern Michigan? There are weeks with zero direct sun, just low cloud cover, scattered snow, and cold cold cold. I was in Michigan once when Lake Superior froze over, shore to shore. Unless the place is so well insulated you can keep it warm purely with body heat, you need supplemental heating in climates like this. The sun is not always shining.
- WalterBright 5y agohttps://permies.com/t/42722/Passive-Solar-House-design-Cloudy https://permies.com/t/42722/Passive-Solar-House-design-Cloud...
- lazide 5y agoAs that thread confirms, you do need backup in a cold climate, even with a ton of insulation. Amounts of insulating including R50 and R70, which is pretty mind blowing (and are difficult and expensive to accomplish in practice due to thermal bridging/‘leaks’). Some folks in less severe climates (like New Hampshire) seemed to get by with baking and other managed appliance heat. That does require you spend time doing, and orient your activities around, things to produce heat to stay warm. Some will find that palatable, others won’t. Posters in Colder climates (like Ontario) noted propane, or thermal mass heaters (such as the rocket heater in the thread). ‘Then the propane could make up the modest difference on long cold cloudy stretches.’ Thanks for linking it!