3 ms·
Why Arabs Lose Wars (1999)
- PaulHoule 5y agoArabs are great irregular combatants but try to organize them in something that looks like a regular army you are doomed.
- petre 5y agoThe LNA is pretty much organised.
- simonblack 5y agoSo tell me, why was it that Europe was nearly conquered by the Arabs and a lot of it occupied for several centuries. They got to the Loire in France around 730 CE. So that was half of France. The last Arabs were finally ejected from Spain in 1492, only 500 years ago. They'd been there for 800 years. The whole of the North African coast, thousands of miles, and South to the Equator, is still held by Arabs after the conquests of around 700 CE, so roughly 1300 years ago.
- kjellsbells 5y agoThis is a miscomparison of tenses. The peninsular Arab armies of 700-1300 were unstoppable. But the parent commenter is asking about the armies of the modern era. Actually a more interesting question is why /regular/ armies organized by the State in such countries are generally perceived as hopeless whereas /irregular/ militias such as we see in Afghanistan have proven so effective. It's clearly not a people thing since they are drawn from the same well.
- 1cvmask 5y ago
- kjellsbells 5y agoThe question, 20 years later is, does it matter. All recent wars in the ME have been asymmetric, and in such wars the indigenous "irregular" forces invariably win. Perhaps it doesn't matter that Arab culture is unlike the US counterpart when we have spent a trillion dollars in two wars and lost both.