6 ms·
> Any advert in a public space that gives you no choice whether you see it or not is yours Welcome to public spaces? Life involves maybe seeing things, idea,
by duxup 5y ago
> Any advert in a public space that gives you no choice whether you see it or not is yours
Welcome to public spaces?
Life involves maybe seeing things, idea, people you don’t like. That’s not inherently bad.
- jtdev 5y ago
- drorco 5y agoIt brings up an interesting question. I live in Israel where there are constant conflicts about what is OK to be shown in public, especially between the religious and non-religious. In Jerusalem for example, some ultra-orthodox often vandalize any kind of poster that shows a woman in it. They just tear-out/spray over the women on the poster. Some are ridiculous cases where they defaced a poster of an old woman who survived the holocaust: https://www.timesofisrael.com/female-holocaust-survivors-portrait-defaced-for-3rd-time-at-jerusalem-exhibit/ https://www.timesofisrael.com/female-holocaust-survivors-por... Even other groups could be pissed by posters that include things about women's hygiene or show models in swimsuits. In their eyes these are things they make a lot of effort to block from the eyes of their families, and having it in public breaches the culture and education they try to maintain. This is by itself interesting as public adverts can penetrate the most strict censorship that religious groups and cults maintain. Seculars on the other hand can also be pissed about anti-abortion adverts, religious propaganda, scientology, etc. and ask for them to be banned. As someone who's trying to be a "free-thinker" and tries to promote it, I think there's no point in hiding in a bubble, blocking yourself from seeing other ideas, even if they're crappy advertisements. All of this as long as the adverts/ideas fit within the aesthetics of the city they're in. The risk of doing so is essentially losing free-thinking and some sort of communication with isolated social groups.
- b3morales 5y agoCan we make a distinction between postings for different purposes, though? For example, commercial, political, and public education. Do a Coca-cola billboard, a sign advocating a piece of legislation, and a poster about the local library all get the exact same level of deference?
- drorco 5y agoYes. There are laws in some countries for example that make the advertising of Tobacco illegal. That's a form of censorship people can say is reasonable, but it can also be a slippery slope towards harsher censorship around other things people might find harmful - the female body, sugar, gambling, abortion, meat, etc. The question is if you want to give the government such a broad spectrum to censor, in which they'd start judging whether or not a product might be deemed potentially harmful.
- berkes 5y agoThen why is Coca Cola allowed to promote their proven harmful sugar juices in that space, but am I not allowed to oppose that promotion in the same space? What is allowed and tolerated in that public space is skewed, an unfair. Certainly not balanced.
- duxup 5y agoIt sounds like you just substitute what you don’t like for what want to see? I don’t think that had anything to do with what I said. Although I’m curious What would a not “skewed” public space looks like, and how do you manage that?
- rolph 5y agothe whole point is you dont manage a public space, we do. the public space is a construct of what we allow it to be
- berkes 5y agoIf I sounded like that, I should have spent more effort. Sorry. What I was trying to bring across, is that it is "public space" which implies it equally belongs to everyone. But that this is not the case for what you are allowed to advertise. Corporations, or at least "those with connections and/or money" are allowed to be heard a lot more than anyone who lacks these connections or funds. I call that "skewed". A fair and level "public space" would give anyone, regardless of how much money, connections or lawyers they have, the same ability to present their message. I am not saying that this would always be a good thing; because this probably means far more advertising noise. It would probably turn our streets into a printed version of twitter. Ugh. I am trying to say that in order to make this less skewed, "those with money, connections and/or lawyers" should also not be allowed to use that public space to deliver their messages. That is a level playing field too!
- marklubi 5y ago> Then why is Coca Cola allowed to promote their proven harmful sugar juices in that space, but am I not allowed to oppose that promotion in the same space? You are certainly allowed to. Pony up for the ad space if you want to promote the opposite, or advertise something else entirely.
- SyzygistSix 5y agoSao Paulo made all billboards and ads illegal. It's a thing. People can do it if they want. I'm pretty sure they don't allow billboards in some states in the US.
- ipaddr 5y agoAlaska, Hawaii, Maine and Vermont
- MomoXenosaga 5y agoSeems Brazil still has its priorities straight.
- user3939382 5y agoWithout getting into the politics of the personhood (or lack thereof) of corporations, we can say at least that it's not quite that simple since there have been places (is Sao Paulo one?) that have banned outdoor advertising. That means the representatives of the people there came to a consensus that corporate marketing is not on equal footing with the expression of other ideas.
- MomoXenosaga 5y agoStreet musicians. Draaiorgels (youtube it but keep your finger close to mute). Protestors. Homeless. Tourists. English tourists. Pigeons. Why do we live in a city again?