3 ms·
This is typically discussed in terms of: - Avoided negative externalities. FB/Google get to ignore the costs of insufficient moderation by imposing those on t
by dredmorbius 5y ago
This is typically discussed in terms of:
- Avoided negative externalities. FB/Google get to ignore the costs of insufficient moderation by imposing those on their users or third parties (say, the victims of the Myanmar genocide).
- Monopoly rents. By securing a position in which they are the arbiters of access control, these giants can set both prices and terms for participation.
There's another element you're suggesting to me as well, which I don't think I've seen anyone articulate before: large monopoly players such as Facebook and Google effectively emerge into a "naive environment", one in which the scale which they provide has not yet evolved threats. Any threats which do emerge co-evolve with the monopoly.
Subsequent entrants don't have this advantage. Whilst they do have the benefit of techniques for combatting such threats, they must address the threats from the beginning.
The threats might variously be spammers, various network attacks (most especially DDoS), sockpuppet and other misrepresentation and manipulation attacks, harrassment, and the usual laundry list of Trust & Safety issues.
The notion of co-evolving threats comes from biology generally, though I'd strongly recommend Kyle Harper's The Fate of Rome which postulates that civilisations (themselves social networks) and their plagues co-evolve alongside one another. I've just learned that the Santa Fe Institute crowd are fans of Harpers (Geoffrey West and David Krakauer, in a recent Complexity podcast episode), as well as Neal Stephenson.
- Dracophoenix 5y agoA few contentions: - "Insufficient" moderation is not a cause for an externality. The default level of moderation in any system, whether in nature or on the Internet, is zero. To imply otherwise is is fallacious thinking. There is no duty of care on Facebook's part to prevent bad actors from using its services anymore than there's a duty of care for a random passer-by to stop a mugging. - How does monopoly rent exist when nothing is being charged to the to the end-user?
- dredmorbius 5y agoEven the slightest degree of consideration will reveal multiple errors here. When one possible outcome of failure to moderate is, for example, genocide, then yes a duty exists. https://nypost.com/2021/12/07/rohingya-refugees-sue-facebook-for-stoking-myanmar-genocide/ https://nypost.com/2021/12/07/rohingya-refugees-sue-facebook... We've seen what the natural state of even modestly-sized fora with no effective moderation is. They simply don't function. You'll find this in real-world spaces as well, in the forms of attractive nuisance, negligence, joint liability, and other forms. There are reasons venues provide security in potentially volatile crowd situations, from bars and nightclubs to sports arenas.