4 ms·
Why do people write comments even if no one reads them?
I saw this on forums and now on social media. People write comments that almost always get ignored or remain unread. On HN, comments that are way down the page have almost no chance of being noticed and replied to by others, and yet people write comments on HN.
Why do you think that is? Do you ever try to "force" attention to your comment by replying to top comments even if your comment is not relevant to the OP?
- ggm 5y agoI write comments to myself. Why that lambda got used, where I stole it from. They're for a stranger: future me. I reread my code frequently stealing snippets from my past self. It helps if you code well, and can remember stuff but if not, comments are the next best thing. I don't code well, my memory is shot, I need all the help I can get these last forty years. README.md is somewhat replacing this. Typically I embed backtick quoted execution sequences, shell pipes, how I invoke this instance of that lambda, with some sugar for argument parsing, input pre-processing. Then if you upload to some git repo you get it all: code you can search, some freetext which may match search index terms you're hunting on from the comments, and a documented example of using it on real data.
- ggm 5y agoHah. I should have read better.
- GianFabien 5y agoI presume you mean comments on social media and not comments in source code. I only write comments when I feel that I can make a contribution by commenting. Once a HN post becomes more than a page or so, I generally find that somebody has already written what I would have written, so I don't add to it. Specific to HN, I find that subsets of comments on comments explore various tangents of interest to some posters. These can be very interesting, although sometimes I feel they would be better handled as a fresh thread.
- pksebben 5y agoIt's not necessarily true that comments at the bottom don't get read - I personally tend to read exhaustively those comment threads that are on topics I really care about. > Do you ever try to "force" attention to your comment by replying to top comments even if your comment is not relevant to the OP? Please, please, please don't do this. It screws up the flow of a conversation and generally degrades the quality of the site. It's super rude.