3 ms·
> The proxies like Squid can do HTTPS intercepting so I was wondering what's the point of TLS anyway? If you 1) choose to use a proxy and 2) that is a proxy yo
by blablabla123 5y ago
> The proxies like Squid can do HTTPS intercepting so I was wondering what's the point of TLS anyway?
If you 1) choose to use a proxy and 2) that is a proxy you don't trust, then TLS is pointless for your use case. (Edit: you need to actually activate proxy usage)
I'm using home internet since the mid 90s and I think none of the ISPs I ever used required a proxy. (Mobile excluded, I'm certainly no mobile expert anyway) But I'm aware of ISPs in the late 90s that required ISP proxy usage.
Personally at some point I had set up a local squid to speed up my internet. But today? I think only really bad ISPs and some corporate networks use that. In the latter case it might make sense since you deal with corporate data/code that is owned by BigCorp anyway.
Regarding the CA stuff: yes sure but well, that's the point of the CA. You trust it, some OSs require you to explicitly install those if that matches your risk profile. But really, if you're at that point, maybe the far riskier attack vector is someone shoulder surfing or stealing your laptop?
That said, yes there's certificate transparency but I think it's still experimental and at that level of paranoia you might be optimizing/focussing on the wrong thing.
- josephcsible 5y agoOP is talking about transparent/intercepting proxying, not proxying that you choose to use.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- blablabla123 5y agoTrue which kind of excludes the usage of Squid, but that's even more effort because either one specific domain needs to be targeted or a whole cluster of domains. I mean the moment someone finds this out and publishes the public cert that has been used on HN the CA that issued it will be out of business within a month. Afterwards there would be a lot of fuzz and everybody might go all-in on CT. IMHO the most realistic attack vector in this context is a bug in TLS or a popular implementation that is being leveraged to target an individual. Whoever is in this situation, should seriously consider the way he or she uses the internet...