3 ms·
Nice work! How many transistors does it have in all? They could have used an LFSR for the PC too. Would that have saved some area? If not, I wonder why they u
by kragen 5y ago
Nice work!
How many transistors does it have in all?
They could have used an LFSR for the PC too. Would that have saved some area? If not, I wonder why they used them elsewhere.
Are the resets (on 10000...) synchronous? If not I wonder how they handled glitch safety.
- kens 5y agoI estimate about 1500 transistors. Yes, they could have used the LFSR for the PC; I've seen that in early microcontrollers. I actually expected to see a LFSR there. Maybe they wanted to have a linear ROM layout to make their life simpler. Yes, the resets are synchronous.
- kragen 5y agoThank you very much! I wonder if you could do a CMOS μC in 1500 transistors; my best ideas so far are barely under 3000. Of course to make music that way you need a much faster clock plus some code memory.
- RodgerTheGreat 5y agoThe Intel 4004 had 2250 transistors, and it was designed to work in concert with support chips, unlike a modern MCU. A quick search doesn't turn up any known models with fewer. 1500 for an MCU might be possible, but it'd be a tight squeeze. Registers and multiplexers chew through transistors rather quickly.
- kragen 5y agoThe 4004 had to go fast enough to run a calculator at 0.75 MHz though. A modern chip typically runs at 100 MHz and can run at 4 GHz. If you could fab it in indium phosphide (which wouldn't be CMOS!) you could maybe run it at 400 GHz and use an optical fiber as a delay-line memory, 1 bit per millimeter. This sort of thing might enable you to use less transistors than a 4004. I got down about that low with a bit-serial design whose only arithmetic instruction was a subtract, but I haven't simulated it at even the RTL level, just done a gate-level design on paper and a couple of software instruction-level sims.