4 ms·
> we don't need It's not difficult to imagine a situation in which someone does not /strictly/ need a car (it also seems urban life is quite common these days)
by mdp2021 5y ago
> we don't need
It's not difficult to imagine a situation in which someone does not /strictly/ need a car (it also seems urban life is quite common these days). It should also be extremely easy to imagine having a car as extremely beneficial.
(By the way: epidemics still being far from forgotten, it's really odd to paint collective, "public" transport as aproblematic.)
Now, to attack the problem, one could also (and in some contexts primarily) hit house heating. There are voices recommending heating limited to 16°C/61°F. The issue is just about quality of life. Including enabling operations. Hacker should be attentive on their instruments, since they are instrument crafters.
Since the control of resources has always been linked to their price (which is also equivalent to, or actually including, an externality tax) - so given a clear alternative -, I am not sure how the whole idea of "we will do without", restricting "freedom" (in abstract terms, as a primary value for constitutional decisors) and operation, came to be.
(Up to not seeing "the car" as a life changing revolution... Reading just recently the first pages of a history text, the car was immediately mentioned as "expanding the possibilities for movement to unimaginable heights even for the richest of fifty years before". It has always been very clearly a most prominent gift of engineering, as if a third dotation of natural limbs: it's odd to now read about it as "negligible".)
- kiba 5y agoIt's not difficult to imagine a situation in which someone does not /strictly/ need a car (it also seems urban life is quite common these days). It should also be extremely easy to imagine having a car as extremely beneficial. Interurban rails and other form of mass transit gained prominence especially in the early 20th century. They were eventually outcompeted by cars on a wide variety of factors, including public support for funding of roads. It's not too difficult to imagine freight traveling on streetcar rails. (Up to not seeing "the car" as a life changing revolution... Reading just recently the first pages of a history text, the car was immediately mentioned as "expanding the possibilities for movement to unimaginable heights even for the richest of fifty years before". It has always been very clearly a most prominent gift of engineering, as if a third dotation of natural limbs: it's odd to now read about it as "negligible".) The car is simply not as viable without proper infrastructure and implicit subsidies.
- mdp2021 5y ago> It's not too difficult to imagine freight traveling on streetcar rails So? What do you mean, what is your conclusion from that? You wrote that «we don't need ... cars». I wrote that you don't "need" (much) heating either, relevantly to impact, but the impact on quality of life can be massive. Try performing intellectual (reduced motion, in general) activities in the cold. Try buying groceries without a car when living in a very low density, non urbanized area. Maybe you don't care about the advantages of a car: to others they are vital. > The car is simply not as viable without proper infrastructure and implicit subsidies So? What do you mean? You dismissed the car as expendable, I noted that it has been called an historical revolution with a massive impact in the quality of one's life, for good.
- toast0 5y ago> The car is simply not as viable without proper infrastructure and implicit subsidies. Cars work fine on dirt paths. Not as good as on roads, but they still work. Sure, it's tricky to go through a forest, but otherwise they're ok.
- denton-scratch 5y agoMost cars are parked by the roadside most of the time (constricting the cariageway). If most people who needed a car could just pick one up at their chosen departure point and abandon it at their destination, and if that were massively cheaper than private ownership (which it should be, because shared cars would see much greater utilization), that would slash the number of cars on the road. If these were self-driving, then presumably if the model you want doesn't happen to be at your departure point, you could just ask it to come to you.