3 ms·
Many years ago I had to take mandatory privacy training for some contracting I was doing for a non-profit (open source case management for homeless shelters in
by cmrdporcupine 5y ago
Many years ago I had to take mandatory privacy training for some contracting I was doing for a non-profit (open source case management for homeless shelters in Toronto).
It was actually quite informative. And what I got out of it is that I "trust" the public / government institutions in Canada a lot more than I do private ones. Yes, they're often incompetent. Yes, I'm sure there are rules broken. But years of working in the private sector and seeing how cavalier user's PII was treated vs the legal protections actually expected of government agencies... There are very stringent regulations in place on the who/what/where of data that comes into public agencies.
There is a tone in this thread, from some, of an intrinsic expectation of malice by the state. But I actually have more expectation of responsibility by layers of governance here than I do of private entities, which are generally further outside of my control or visibility, often keeping my data in American data centres, etc.
- anotheraccount9 5y agoAfter working for Canada's Defence, I certainly don't trust how they protect military members' medical data. It's on a separate network which requires asymmetric crypto for access, but the actual data has yet to be encrypted. I think that's unsafe, considering how it's common practice now.
- sandworm101 5y ago>> but the actual data has yet to be encrypted. You probably don't want to look too closely at how medical records are being kept in the private sector. Encryption is supposed to be a rule but the exceptions and loopholes mean very little is properly encrypted. Most medical privacy rules can be met by implementing drive-level encryption, transparent encryption that protects only against hard drives being stolen but does nothing to prevent data extraction from a live drive. A small medical office can probably get away with simply turning on bitlocker.
- Mezzie 5y agoI trust the moral judgement of the average government worker more than I do the moral judgement of the average Big Tech worker or CEO, but I trust the technical competence of the Big Tech workers more. I expect the government to try to protect my information from everyone except for themselves, but fail to account for what I consider basic security practices. I expect Big Tech to be safer from malicious hacks and tech exploits, but they'll sell my info to the highest bidder. Basically one is an unlocked but well-guarded warehouse and one is a warehouse that requires 50 keys to open and is on the ocean floor but the warehouse company also runs key-stamping and submarine businesses.
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoSure, I agree, I think you basically restated what my proposition. The key thing is that we can fix the technical problems in government. But the privacy failures of the private sector are built into the predominant business models of the tech sector itself and harder to fix. (Full disclosure, I worked in ads for many years before walking away in disgust) I should say that -- coming off a 10 year stint at Google -- Google takes PII super seriously and does a very good job of protecting it technically and organizationally. I'm sure most other BigTechs do, too. But clearly this data, people's private data and models of behaviour etc based on that, is a major source of revenue in our industry. Another point on this topic: Governments and do act with malice to their populations in some situations, but in general Canadians have higher expectations of, and higher trust for, their government than Americans seem to on the whole. Hence our single payer health system and the classic motto of 'Peace, Order, and Good Government' which characterizes our commonwealth vs the 'Life, Liberty, and Pursuit of Happiness' etc. of the American Republic.
- labawi 5y agoTo be fair, that only applies to big tech and some fraction of non-tech companies. The rest have a fairly cavalier attitude towards computer security.
- t0suj4 5y agoHow do you think the circumstances and motivations of a government employee differ from those of a CEO?