3 ms·
I've experimented with labeling search results that contain js, amazon-links, video, analytics/tracking, etc. on search.marginalia.nu; you can also require/excl
by marginalia_nu 5y ago
I've experimented with labeling search results that contain js, amazon-links, video, analytics/tracking, etc. on search.marginalia.nu; you can also require/exclude results by those standards. Seems to work reasonably well, even if there are some false positives.
> Better metadata search, and inclusion / exclusion by category, would be great. Search exclusive to scientific, technical, or academic sites, or exclusive of commercial, paywall, erotic, gaming sites, for example. (Such filters could of course be reversed if that was your kink.) Inclusion/exclusion of social media is probably another big one.
I would like to do this, but I'm not quite sure how I'd implement the labeling. .edu and .ac.xx works for academia for the most part, but the rest is a lot harder. Could possibly be done approximately using graph adjacency, but I don't know how you'd get a true-false value out of it...
- dredmorbius 5y agoThere's a microformats spec, which isn't closely followed, and even organisations which should get things right foul up all the time. Example: Wired apparently can't properly distinguish authors of additional articles and the author(s) of the principle displayed article in a manner that Pocket could reliably parse, or at least wasn't doing this at some point in time. So my saved Wired articles were listing a dozen or two authors, most of whom had nothing to do with the article in question. My experience is that quality data isn't provided unless it becomes critical for function and/or revenue, and most likely the latter. If bad metadata earns a search penalty and whatever site is penalising has a sufficient impact on search results, then you'll see shifts. A minority search platform won't be able to do that initially, though if its results are useful, it could easily capture a large share of the high-value search community, which would give it outsized impact even with small usage. (Think of Apple's position as a hardware provider to a small but affluent market.)
- marginalia_nu 5y agoI think, in general, attempting to shape websites through search ranking has deleterious effects on search results. The ones most likely to comply are the worst, spammiest websites. The result is that you filter out websites made by people (who don't necessarily care about search ranking), and what you promote is the sort of content mills that do care a lot about search ranking. For example, only about 25% of the sites I index use HTTPS. If you, like Google say "I want to promote HTTPS adoption by only indexing HTTPS sites", you are throwing an awful number of babies out with that bathwater.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThe principle reason I'd like to see sites ranked lower for specific usage patterns is because those patterns severely degrade the Web experience for me. And I feel I'm not alone. So: make it hurt a bit to do stupid stuff. Fighting spam through standards compliance and elegant site design is not the principle account. There should be other indicia of spam which are readily apparent, and used. But any site, spammy or otherwise, which flagrantly abuses dark patterns, should pay a penalty for doing so.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoRight, this does very little to actual stop spam, it just makes them change up how they operate. It's key to realize that almost the only people who actually keep up with all the hoops you have to jump through to get a good rating are the actual spammers, to the point where my search engine rewards not following Google's rules with the result of getting an amazing signal-to-noise ratio with very little spam. That is, the most reliable hint that a website is SEO spam is that it religiously adheres to Google's recommendations. Of course, this inversion only works if you're an underdog. Big search engines are fucked by their own success.
- dredmorbius 5y agoAs emphatically as I can state this: this is not at all addressed at spam. I suspect that the pressure will be more effective than you're portraying. Few people hand-tool webites. Most use tools for generation and management, with Wordpress accounting for a tremendous portion of the Web itself. Tool builders tend to aim for utility, particularly with encouragement.