5 ms·
Germany’s Sovereign Tech Fund: Strengthening Digital Infrastructure+Open Source
- test0account 5y agoWhy do governments feel compelled to constantly intervene in businesses? What market failure (apparently unique to Germany) are they fixing? Edit: I have like 4 different responses. 1) Open source is a human right, 2) security is a mess, 3) China has proven an invasive industrial policy can be successful, and 4) Government intervention is important to prevent wealth imbalances So my conclusion given the lack of consensus is that this fund is totally pointless.
- mahmoudhossam 5y agoMaybe not unique to Germany, but the market failing to properly fund and support OSS software projects?
- j-pb 5y agoThe mess we're in, in terms of software security and reliability, when it comes to the infrastructure that runs our world is a textbook case-study on how a free market with profit incentives is neither an efficient nor effective driver of an economic system. The drive for unsustainably externalised costs in both resource and labour exploitation, colloquially known as "pay peanuts, get monkeys", creates brittle systems with short term returns. The whole idea of infinite returns in the limit due to steady return from a one time investment is just a different spin on a perpetuum mobile. Entropy incurs a regular cost, be it supply chains, tools, workers, or software.
- hrhrhrhrhr 5y agoThat's not really fair, software security is better than ever.
- newlisp 5y agoHey, came across a comment of yours https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25499058 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25499058 in search engine results while researching the reasons to why learn Clojure as my next programming language. I'm curious if you have change your mind about it or still prefer JS for new projects? One thing that I find attractive about Clojure is Datomic (databases being a source of complexity in applications), its features like immutability(the db as a value, history), data structures as query language not strings, transactions and data model, OTOH, it's a scary niche black box. Also, the clojure REPL is a nice addition. I'm no stranger to lisps, having played with scheme and racket, know macros, watched some Hickey videos and overall understand clojure's philosophy and concepts but haven't never use it for a real world business application. I'm sure nodejs/postgres could suit my needs perfectly but the ergonomics/defaults of clojure/datomic makes me think things would be less tedious to develop.
- Bromeo 5y agoThe statement here is that some "basic digital infrastructure" like compilers or security protocols are fundamental to every individuals participation in the "digital revolution". Therefore the government wants to fund some of this basic infrastructure in order to prevent it from going closed-source or proprietary. The point is that open-source software is not and should not be regulated by the market, as it should not be profit driven.
- cappr 5y agoBut it should be regulated by a committee of people with no excellent open source histories?
- Bromeo 5y agoEstablishing a fund is not the same as regulating the beneficiary. Compare for example with academia - universities in Europe are overwhelmingly government funded, yet they get a lot of freedom in what research they conduct.
- _fizz_buzz_ 5y agoHow do you know the evaluators won't have any open source history? Usually people who evaluate this proposals will have domain knowledge.
- Xylakant 5y agoWhat constitutes an "excellent open source history"? People that code often don't want to be bothered by organization and financial matters, and vice-versa, community work is still often disregarded as not truly open source work. Some people did sit down, did all the leg-work of getting funding for a study, did a study, published it (open source under CC-BY) - including a plan for the setup of the fund, cost analysis, how many people to employ and their pay (btw: roughly 10% of the budget, which seems reasonable at first glance), legal analysis of three funding models (1) and then someone with a random new internet account complains about their open source history (2) and their gender (3) (1) the government can't just go throw money at people without rules. (2) they at least have a published 50 page study (3) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29683265 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29683265
- odiroot 5y agoBeing generally conservative (and especially in business) would be the main reason. Cannot go wrong with the government after all, right? Second reason may be strong lobbying from legacy IT concerns. They usually get government contracts and are usually viable for support from such funds.
- hnhg 5y agoIt's not unique to Germany. For example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In-Q-Tel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In-Q-Tel
- JaimeThompson 5y agoIf only the government had not intervened, via ARPA, to push packed switched networking and had allowed AT&T to keep doing what they did just imagine what the Internet would be today!
- mrtksn 5y agoYou can expect this to happen more and more as China demonstrated that innovation is indeed possible by government intervention. Another thing that was demonstrated at exactly same time was that it is possible to have decade long stagnation in an open market. I'm talking about the state of the Web and mobile has come to in the hands of FB, Google and others in the free market with no government interventions. The biggest sensation since many years is (China government supported) TikTok and the "free market" response to it was to try to ban it or force purchase it. My hope is, that countries like USA and UK will re-think their understanding of fairness in a free market and once again we will have fair and innovative free business environment but at this time and stage there's evidence that governmental intervention can yield innovation in stagnated markets. In this exact case, people at the German government are targeting a specific risk of foundational elements in tech being underfunded or overprotected.
- Nullinker 5y agoBecause it is one of the primary functions of the government to prevent excesses in the free market so that generated wealth is spread out over many people in society as opposed to a only a few. Because people consider that unfair it often leads to destabilizing society causing even more suffering.
- FlyingSnake 5y ago> Examples of digital infrastructure include code libraries or standardized protocols used by developers to write and test application software. Not everything is business and there should be support for new infrastructure that falls outside the purview of businesses. I’m glad there’s some initiative from my Govt to address digital infrastructure woes. It’ll be interesting to see how it’ll pan out. However The most important thing is a periodic audit to avoid a Luca App like situation.
- xblpark 5y agoWho would do the audit? The people capable of doing so are either in major open source projects or in industry and have no time. Many government initiatives in Germany support friends and family and have poor results or none. Below someone is mentioning ARPA. I can assure you that nothing remotely like ARPA will come out of this. Different country, different times. Before any money is handed out, first I'd like to know who appointed the organizers and for what reason.
- FlyingSnake 5y agoI don’t know who can do the audit and that is my biggest concern about such initiatives apart from Nepotism. The fact that the Govt seems to be involved in optics rather than installing checks and balances makes me nervous. The fiascos of Luca app and Corona-warn reeks of graft and incompetence.
- cappr 5y agoThe people listed in the study are all female and have also been involved in the application-oriented https://prototypefund.de https://prototypefund.de . The language used and the fact that the same persons are involved in two government funded funds strongly suggests that this is a diversity initiative in disguise. The more I see of open source foundations and funds, the more I think that in many cases the prime beneficiaries are the organizers (though I don't have proof in this case and will not claim it).
- rhamzeh 5y ago> The people listed in the study are all female > strongly suggests that this is a diversity initiative in disguise It would be great if we can use this logic backwards. For any team or initiative we see that is all male, we treat it like a discrimination initiative in disguise. If you don't treat every situation of the above of all male teams/projects/funds like that, I am not sure why you do so in this case. --- Edit: Update formatting
- tacitusarc 5y agoI think the question here is about probabilities. What is the likelihood of particular gender ratios within particular fields? If this were in the field of nursing which is dominated by women, I would be very surprised to see a group of (exclusively) men leading some advocacy/project.
- greatpostman 5y agoOh please
- xblpark 5y agoYou omitted "the language used", also look at the "prototype fund" and some of its sponsored projects.
- test0account 5y agoCorrect. The government has a spending target, let's say 56% of GDP (that is taxes, how much you can borrow from creditors, and how much money printing you can afford). Then they divide that money in categories, and it turns out IT industrial policy got allocated that much money, which they divide into projects. In this project, they build a comittee, which decides the best is to subsidise cool sounding initiatives by well connected, politically correct groups. Top to bottom government spending that goes wasted in politically connected groups that give nothing back to society.
- jpfr 5y agoFunding basic infrastructure as open source is a great idea. And the only way to keep a market economy going. Otherwise the infrastructure is used increasingly to lock out small competitors. However, I see a distinct lack of “geeks” in this initiative. Instead a lot of pol-sci majors that want to “manage” / claim developments they themselves would not have the skills to build.
- FlyingSnake 5y ago> I see a distinct lack of “geeks” in this initiative I feel the same. Germany has a strong undercurrent of great open source developers and I hope the bureaucracy won’t come in the way of helping the geeks/hackers.
- oytis 5y agoAren't they just going to allocate funding to pre-existing projects? They don't have to be geeks to do that.
- Xylakant 5y ago> Instead a lot of pol-sci majors that want to “manage” / claim developments they themselves would not have the skills to build Very few geeks have the skills (or even the desire) to build a financially sustainable open source project. The projects that are financially sustainable, are often tied to corporate ownership, often one of the FAANG. Still, the work to build the financial and community framework for such a project is often valued at close to, or even less than zero - as your comment shows. There's a lot of talk in the open source world about funding, or rather the lack thereof. Still, comments such as yours downtalk every effort people invest as profiteering of open source work. Wonder why no one wants to do that work - it's thankless, hard, undervalued and underappreciated, even by the ones that would profit of it - the people doing the coding. Your comment is doing all efforts to provide funding for open source projects a disservice.
- jpfr 5y agoOn the contrary. I am very much in favor of people that put in the effort to support the organization around open source. But it should be done by persons that also have insight in the technical work. Otherwise problems of judgment cannot be avoided. That’s the same in every profession by the way. You want to be head of the carpenters guild? Work as a carpenter for some time. Even if it is just carpentry as a hobby. You don’t like it as a hobby? Well, that says a lot already. There is ample organization and leadership skill among the geeks. Look at the site you are on and its background. Many millionaire geeks...
- sam_lowry_ 5y agoSo far, Germany excelled only in funding fringe security like finding open ports and nagging admins all over the world about it.