3 ms·
This is the story that is told, but one can’t avoid the similarity between the South’s alliance with the US, AUS, NZ, Korea and the North’s with the USSR and Ch
by refurb 5y ago
This is the story that is told, but one can’t avoid the similarity between the South’s alliance with the US, AUS, NZ, Korea and the North’s with the USSR and China (which had many soldier stationed there). Without material support the USSR and China provided, the North never could have won the war.
There was no “rightful” liberation. It was a civil war in its essence with two opposing groups of Vietnamese fighting for control of a fractured post-colonial state, with plenty of foreign interference/assistance during the whole thing.
In the end the North did a better job (through both smart politics, good PR and internal support/oppression of opposition).
- sofixa 5y ago> This is the story that is told, but one can’t avoid the similarity between the South’s alliance with the US, AUS, NZ, Korea and the North’s with the USSR and China (which had many soldier stationed there). Without material support the USSR and China provided, the North never could have won the war The difference is that with no outside meddling and support, South Vietnam wouldn't have existed or would have existed very briefly until a Communist electoral victory of the whole country. Without the US in Vietnamese affair, there is no North-South war.
- refurb 5y agoI’d have to disagree on the popular vote. By the time of the proposed election, the Communists had complete control of the Northern population. There was no “free” vote for unification - any more than there would be a free vote in Vietnam today. And the US didn’t get significantly involved (beyond material support for the French) in Vietnam until the early 1960’s with the help of military advisors. The build up didn’t start until around ‘65 when it was apparent the South would collapse (through a combination of communist subversion but also a lot of in fighting) The South existed as an independent state for a few years - barely, I would agree. But it existed.
- the_af 5y agoThe South never existed without US backing. It was a made up thing, without popular support, ruled by successive dictatorships (some even had to be toppled with the ok of the US, so terrible they were). It's not your right to decide whether people have free will or not. It's their call. "Deciding" for them is called colonialism. Ho Chi Minh had huge popular support; precisely what the US feared. PS: before the US fucked things up, Ho Chi Minh even looked up to them and fully expected their support against the French. That's how bad the US fucked up.
- refurb 5y agoAnd the North would never had existed without USSR and China’s backing. I’m not sure what your point is? And your comment about “free will” is telling. How much “free will” do the Vietnamese have today? The only difference is it’s Vietnamese elite that control the masses, not some foreign power.
- the_af 5y ago> And the North would never had existed without USSR and China’s backing. False. Did you know the Viet Minh initially counted with support from the US? When it was an anti Japanese struggle, of course. Initial US assessments even thought the French should get the fuck out; those sentiments were overruled by others in the US, sadly. The Vietnamese struggle was a struggle of national liberation. Aided from the outside like all resistance organizations, sure -- like the French resistance against the Nazis was. Didn't make France any less real. Imagine if the Allies had partitioned France in two after the war, claimed the last Nazi held parts were to be ruled by Germany's successors or whatever, and that the ensuing fight to reunify France was "a civil war" and that the free (non German) France was "just as artificial". > I’m not sure what your point is? That the US sided with colonial powers and against an independence movement. Not their finest hour. > How much “free will” do the Vietnamese have today? More than they would have had had the US backed dictatorship won. Not that it matters: it's not for you to decide. There's no White Man's Burden to send civilization to other countries. Let them have their self determination and arrange their governments how they like. Above all, don't murder them by the thousands, destroy the countryside and poison their land when you don't like the government they choose.
- tasogare 5y agoJust like South Korea. It's sad so many lives were lost and the current situation is impossible to solve because of former US involvement.
- moksly 5y agoThis is the sort of distorting of history the article speaks about. Vietnam was invaded by the French in the 1800 and turned into a colony. That colony was lost, and then semi-regained over the course of WW2 and the years following. When the French lost and withdrew, America invaded and was subsequently beaten. This is not a defence of China or Russia, look at how they are invading Tibet and the Ukraine, but the Vietnamese people weren’t invaded by China or the USSR, they were invaded by the US. South-Vietnam was an American fabrication during its invasion following the post French-Indonesian-war, because the Vietnamese people had a government in Hanoi, the US simply didn’t like it.
- refurb 5y agoNo, you’re distorting history. After the communist victory at Dien Bien Phu, the French negotiated a peace (without much choice) that forced them to give up the North (where the communists were strongest). The French slowly disengaged from the South over the next decade leaving a fragile Vietnamese government in the South that had no interest in joining the communists in the North (1 million fled during partition). The US did back a fractured, unstable government in the South in order to contain communism - I’m not arguing that. But to claim that the country, one that lasted 20 years, wasn’t “real” is just silly. It’s like saying South Korea isn’t real because the UN backs it’s security and the communists had significant support prior to partition.
- the_af 5y agoThe US propped up a dictatorship in the South and canceled free elections because they knew Ho Chi Minh would win. This is a matter of recorded fact, not a conspiracy theory. They had also been supporting the French with materiel and even limited numbers of advisors during the First Indochina War. There was a war of national liberation against a colonial power, and the US sided with the colonial power.
- refurb 5y agoThis is false. Of course Ho Chi Minh would win - there were no free elections in the North (100% of votes went for him!) and substantial support in the South. I wouldn’t call that a fair and free election. Yes, and I agree the US supported the French materially and with advisors. But South Vietnam was no longer a colonial power. The French were gone and the Vietnamese called the shots (not without foreign influence, I agree, but similar to the USSR and China influence in the North - you pay the bills you get a say). But none of that infers the South wasn’t a real country.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y ago> In the end the North did a better job (through both smart politics, good PR and internal support/oppression of opposition). And torrents of blood. Americans mourn 58,000 dead, but the NVC lost well north of a million.
- the_af 5y ago> It was a civil war in its essence with two opposing groups of Vietnamese fighting for control of a fractured post-colonial state It wasn't a civil war, not to begin with at least. The US installed a dictatorship in the South (the dictator they propped up was so bad they ended up greenlighting his removal and "accidental" assassination), with the promise of free elections. When predictions showed Ho Chi Minh would have won the elections in the South by a landslide, they simply cancelled the election. That's not Vietnamese vs Vietnamese, it's Vietnamese vs colonial power. In any colonial administration, people cozy with the colonial power will defend it and resent a change, of course.
- refurb 5y agoYour lack of historical knowledge is showing. The US never installed a government in the South. That was the French as a part of the ‘54 Treaty. And your comment about a “free and fair” election makes me laugh. What do you suppose the vote would have been in the North? 100%? Probably. Clearly a lot of Vietnamese opposed the communist regime. They lost, despite the support of the US. And the North won, with the support of China and the USSR. There is not “rightful” winner, just the winner.
- the_af 5y ago> Your lack of historical knowledge is showing. Brave words for someone going against the current consensus about the Vietnam war. Also, please avoid name calling. The US in effect propped up and backed the dictatorship. They also helped topple it and install successive and increasingly incompetent military dictatorships to replace it. Woo! > There is not “rightful” winner, just the winner. Nah, in the case of a national independence movement against colonial oppressors, there's a rightful winner. Their errors and failures are their own, but they were the right side in that war and the US was the wrong side.
- refurb 5y agoNot sure what consensus you’re talking about? Are my facts incorrect? You’re saying the US installed a dictatorship in the South? Are you aware of the treaty in 1956 that created the partition? The US propped up a dictatorship in the South, I agree. And the North was a dictatorship propped up by the Chinese and USSR. The North was fortunate it had purged all opposition long ago so could focus on its insurgency in the South while the South had to deal with a fractured political landscape. I’m not sure how you could look at the last 60 years of dictatorship in Vietnam and say the “right” side won. I mean, the Vietnamese who risked their lives to flee probably disagree with you?