4 ms·
Western or Eastern, Japan occupied Indochina for a few years during WW2, and Ho Chi Minh rose as a big resistance leader opposing them. However for the rest yo
by sofixa 5y ago
Western or Eastern, Japan occupied Indochina for a few years during WW2, and Ho Chi Minh rose as a big resistance leader opposing them.
However for the rest you're on point. South Vietnam was a fake regime propped up by the French initially and then the US, had no legitimacy, wasn't democratic ( which could have been a saving grace for it) and was in US-backed violation of the Geneva conference. That's not to say there weren't anti-communists in Vietnam, they were just a small minority (Ho Chi Minh had very strong support in the North, which was more populous).
- refurb 5y agoSouth Vietnam was certainly not “fake”. Not any more “fake” than any other country. It wasn’t a democracy but neither was the north. And the North also violated numerous treaties including the one where the US pulled out all troops and North agreed to stop further infiltration. The communists certainly had strong support in the North (they had secured power and purged any opposing elements, including within their party). They also had support in the south, but were forced to infiltrate hundreds of thousands over the war to sustain a fighting force as they weren’t able to grow it organically in the South (also shown during the 1968 Tet Offensive where no population center or military unit “flipped” to the communist side).
- trasz 5y agoThis is pure whataboutism.
- refurb 5y agoAre my facts incorrect? If so, please call them out. OP said the North was “right” because the South was X,Y,Z. I countered with “the North also did X,Y,Z.”, thus countering their claims that the North was somehow “more pure or righteous”. Maybe it is whataboutism, but that seems appropriate when someone is trying to claim superiority to another?
- trasz 5y agoI didn’t say your facts are incorrect, I said it’s whataboutism - trying to redirect the discussion away from facts inconvenient to you.
- CrazyStat 5y agoCuriously enough, the accusation of "whataboutism" itself is more often than not an attempt to redirect the discussion away from facts inconvenient to the accuser.
- sofixa 5y ago> South Vietnam was certainly not “fake”. Not any more “fake” than any other country It kind of was though. It was created temporarily until elections are held by a treaty over fears the communists will have control over all of Vietnam ( they would have), and existed solely due to direct and heavy American support. It wasn't a country based on self-determination or anything of the like.
- refurb 5y agoWe’re probably splitting hairs at this point, but there was significant support for an anti-communist government among the Vietnamese. 1M of them migrated South when the French turned the North over to the Communists. Yes I know about the campaign to encourage it, but the land reform purges of the 1950’s certainly helped show who was going to do well in the North and who wouldn’t. And I suppose you could say the same about the American Rebellion. It never would have succeeded without support from the French. Does that mean the fledgling Continental Congress wasn’t a real country?