2 ms·
So long as the carbon is sourced from the biosphere (preferably extracted from seawater or air), and the energy feeding that is carbon-neutral (solar, wind, geo
by dredmorbius 5y ago
So long as the carbon is sourced from the biosphere (preferably extracted from seawater or air), and the energy feeding that is carbon-neutral (solar, wind, geothermal, nuclear, ...) then the net use cycle is carbon-neutral.
There are use cases other than automobiles which would benefit by petroleum-analogue fuels, most especially aircraft and marine shipping, though also some overland freight (trains, trucks), remote off-grid applications, and some portable tools and equipment. Batteries suit some but not all of these cases.
Yes, there's a huge efficiency loss, but the win is in storage, portability, energy density, safety, and on-demand availability. Round-trip recovery would likely be ~15--25%, mostly through hydrolysis losses (~40--50%) and Carnot efficiency (only 25--50% of heat energy produces useful mechanical energy). Those are givens, again, the question is the trade-off and capabilities gained.
There's well over 50 years of research into these technologies. I've summarised and collected this in earlier comments:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21517357 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21517357