2 ms·
> Eh, the article does mention that point: "It only looked at the effects of hospital treatment, but to many that is the crown jewel of medicine." What you quo
by gumby 5y ago
> Eh, the article does mention that point: "It only looked at the effects of hospital treatment, but to many that is the crown jewel of medicine."
What you quote is a mischaracterization by Hanson. From the study (from the GP comment):
> the study was designed to be powered to detect a change in the hospitalization rate, not necessarily changes in health outcomes.
The interesting questions are: which causes a better gross outcome (what Hanson discusses) and, if outcomes are the same which costs less.
If insurance means there is more primary care and that causes less hospitalization then you clearly save money and have a better QoL.
Insurance also handles a different class of cases, e.g. you are hit by a car. These are outlier cases (for which insurance makes the most sense and implies no moral hazard). This is ignored by Hanson who considers only baseline chronic conditions like cholesterol levels.
The study could imply that insurance coverage could be modified (covering less routine care), though more work would be needed. I’m dubious, but that could be the right thing.