6 ms·
This is a feel-good trope that doesn’t remotely reflect the typical situation facing lower income people. Fast food is cultural, not economic. If you go to poor
by rayiner 5y ago
This is a feel-good trope that doesn’t remotely reflect the typical situation facing lower income people. Fast food is cultural, not economic. If you go to poor Asian and Latino neighborhoods in urban areas, you’ll see ethnic grocery stores underpinning a food culture that is independent of fast food. My poor Bangladeshi immigrant relatives don’t eat fast food; they buy food from the halal grocer and cook. What’s been destroyed among native born American poor people is that food culture.
- yardie 5y agoFast food is both cultural and economic. Many immigrant households are very traditional and the woman take on the duty of buying and preparing foods. If you are single American, or single parent, working multiple jobs economically it's more convenient to eat fast food. I have rarely seen immigrant men from non-western countries in any type of grocery store shopping for fresh produce.
- rayiner 5y agoBeing single for an extended time in adulthood, or being a single parent, are cultural as well. And I think the jury is out on “fresh produce” being the key differentiator. It’s hard to find real science that backs that theory up.
- pvg 5y agoI have rarely seen immigrant men from non-western countries in any type of grocery store shopping for fresh produce. https://i.redd.it/h4plv5xwq4861.jpg https://i.redd.it/h4plv5xwq4861.jpg
- tptacek 5y agoThere's something to this, but one has to ask: were your poor Bangladeshi immigrant relatives redlined out of home ownership? I live on a redline boundary street in Chicago and there is a reason that the grocery stores that serve the Black community across that street are on my side of the line.
- rayiner 5y agoNo, during the era of redlining they were living in a third world country, where even an upper middle class family’s apartment looked something like this: https://www.bproperty.com/en/property/details-1890101.html https://www.bproperty.com/en/property/details-1890101.html. The low income NYC and Toronto housing they moved to when they got here wasn’t much of a downgrade. (And of course whatever equity they had wasn’t worth much converted to USD when they came here.)
- tptacek 5y agoRayiner, there is no "era of redlining". De jure redlining is over, but de facto redlining obviously lives on, as you can immediately discern from a 10 minute walk in the west side of Chicago. The point, of course, is that there's a commercial infrastructure in many ethnic neighborhoods that doesn't exist in the redlined neighborhoods due to decades of overt systematic disinvestment. It's why you'll see Mexican groceries every couple blocks in Belmont-Cragin, but only Food and Liquors in Austin. Economic path dependence is a hell of a drug! I don't know if redlining is the only reason for this gap, or even one of the most important, but it's obviously a part of the story. If you're going to make generalizations about entire cultures this way, I think the onus is on you to engage with the history, even if only to say why you think it's not playing a part here.
- rayiner 5y agoThe path dependence argument runs in the other direction. Houses in redlined Black neighborhoods might be worth less than in equivalent white neighborhoods. But they’re worth a lot more than houses in Guatemala or Bangladesh. Likewise, inner city American schools may be worse than schools in affluent suburban neighborhoods in America. But the school in my dad’s village literally had no walls.
- tptacek 5y agoBut we're not talking about why they had whatever food culture they had in Bangladesh. We're talking about what they end up building when they get here. I'm saying one reason why Austin and Lawndale are food deserts, but Belmont-Cragin isn't, is because Belmont-Cragin was regulated differently from Austin and Lawndale. Redlining is a huge big deal; despite ending in the early 1970s, it literally defines the neighborhood boundaries across much of Chicagoland in 2021. And grocery stores are scarce in redlined neighborhoods, but not as much in working class Mexican neighborhoods. Or look at a place like south-suburban Olympia Fields, which is majority Black but wasn't redlined (presumably, it's where a lot of upwardly-mobile families locked into Lawndale and Englewood fled to). Plenty of grocery options. Do you really think redlining has nothing at all to do with this? That seems like an extraordinary claim.