4 ms·
Nitpicks: >How a DDR5-powered MacBook..... LPDDR5, which was correctly labeled later in the article. LPDDR5 is not a variant of DDR5. Hence the title DDR5 po
by ksec 5y ago
Nitpicks:
>How a DDR5-powered MacBook.....
LPDDR5, which was correctly labeled later in the article. LPDDR5 is not a variant of DDR5. Hence the title DDR5 powered is inaccurate.
>Cores have massive L2 blocks for a total of 28 MB of L2.
24MB + 4MB. Only 24MB is shared between HP Cores. There is also an additional 48MB of System Level Cache on Max ( 24MB on Pro ). So in reality the cache difference on Mac system is the reason for most ( but not all ) of the performance difference.
>Printing was done via the 5N TSMC lithography standard.
N5.
>Memory bus was upgraded to LPDDR5 and claims up to 400 GB/s of bandwidth.
On Max only. The Pro only has 200GB/s. As the previous headline claimed with both M1 Pro/Max. Agains this is probably nitpicking.
- masklinn 5y ago> On Max only. The Pro only has 200GB/s. As the previous headline claimed with M1 Pro/Max. Agains this is probably nitpicking. That's already a huge amount for a bloody laptop, probably more relevant is that CPUs are not able to come anywhere near saturating memory bandwidths on the Max: Anandtech tested the memory subsystem[0] and it caps out at around 110 per performance cluster (which you only need 4 cores to reach, with 2 cores already coming close: individual cores reached 102GB/s each), plus around 20 for the efficiency cluster. [0] https://www.anandtech.com/show/17024/apple-m1-max-performance-review/2 https://www.anandtech.com/show/17024/apple-m1-max-performanc...
- ksec 5y agoYes they are only really needed for the GPU. But then I dont want people to think M1 Pro has the same 400GB/s memory bandwidth as M1 Max just from reading the article. Again, nitpicking.
- ben-schaaf 5y ago> That's already a huge amount for a bloody laptop It's about on-par with modern-ish dedicated laptop GPUs. The mid-range GTX 1060 mobile from 2016 does 200GB/s, a RTX 3070 mobile from this year does ~450GB/s.
- Aaargh20318 5y agoSure, for the GPU that’s just pretty decent, but the real advantage is the amount of bandwidth available tot the CPU.
- ac29 5y agoBut its not available to the CPU. A couple posts up the chain has a link showing the CPUs are incapable of coming anywhere close to the full bandwidth of the memory.