4 ms·
Back up and ask why do you share anything from any source? If you have something to say, then, why don't you just say it yourself, instead of referencing someo
by Brian_K_White 5y ago
Back up and ask why do you share anything from any source?
If you have something to say, then, why don't you just say it yourself, instead of referencing someone else saying it?
3rd party, perhaps even recognized or respected, corroboration.
The other source somehow is more authoritative and meaningful than the same message directly from yourself. This idea matters and should be considered because X says it.
But if that source says both sensible and insensible things, espouses both virtuous and venal ideals, then the source has no value as source of authority or credeance.
Rig up a speak&spell to randomly spit out statements. Once in a while, it will say something truthful.
Now, so what? Why would you ever cite that speak&spell, no matter what it said, ever, on anything?
And that's just a random neutral source, not an opinionated one that says actively and intentionally harmful things some % of the time.
Even if the speak&spell says something you agree with and want to repeat, you still go try to find some other source who says the same thing, and unlike the speak&spell, has given anyone any reason to respect.
At the very very least, you acknowledge the weak argument and say "I know it's X saying this but..."