4 ms·
The new Graeber, Dawn of Everything Completely tears apart recent trendy anthro books like Sapiens for ignoring both old and very new research and tries to set
by wahnfrieden 5y ago
The new Graeber, Dawn of Everything
Completely tears apart recent trendy anthro books like Sapiens for ignoring both old and very new research and tries to set a new framework for understanding humanity’s potential
- _ugfj 5y agoThis book is lovely. It made me reflect on our current state of affairs. Covid was and still is a test of the value systems of the so called "Western" or "first world" societies. We have failed this test through and through. On a local level, many people didn't care about their communities enough to mask and vaxx and in turn the communities had no way to pressure them. Many, many people have mental health problems -- and I only mean the pandemic induced ones -- and are suffering alone because we do not help each other. Parents were forced to navigate this modern life with kids suddenly at home trying to distance learn. And, again, there was no help. On a global level, these richer countries didn't supply the poorer countries with vaccines and help to distribute them. More than 80% of the population of Africa is not vaccinated. As humanity, we didn't help each other. Complete failure.
- vishnugupta 5y ago+1 to the book even though I’m still 40% in. > As humanity, we didn't help each other. This was one of the aspects that has stuck with me. Where an indigenous leader visiting Europe comments on affairs of the French society. He says how can you (French) completely ignore the destitute sleeping on your city streets and call yourself a civilized society? If I introspect, it’s clear that, at least in the cities, helping other humans has completely vanished. It’s literally every human for themselves. Community support has completely vanished.
- animal_spirits 5y agoI personally think our modern lack of community here in America is driven by two things: 1. The Suburban Experiment in America [0] 2. The decrease of church membership throughout America [1] I can speak to my second point a bit more in depth. Churches historically were centers of communities and social places. And as time moves on we as a society are (rightly so) becoming very suspicious of religion and churches in our lives (I grew up _very_ religious but I no longer am). In my eyes, modern 21st century Christianity is very very different than it was even before the 1960s. It seems the cultural ideologies have shifted from service oriented to worship oriented. In my evangelical church the focus was on putting Jesus (the symbol) higher than literally everything else in your life in order to achieve "eternal salvation" in heaven. The main focus was just believing that Jesus came back to life after being crucified was the only way to get to heaven. There was less focus on service, empathy, and equality. People are leaving in droves because of this. I can go on about more changes that I've noticed, but I'll spare details. We need to build new in-person social centers that are not built on mythologies and symbolism but instead more focused on society itself like the churches of old were. [0] https://www.strongtowns.org/curbside-chat-1/2015/12/14/americas-suburban-experiment https://www.strongtowns.org/curbside-chat-1/2015/12/14/ameri... [1] https://news.gallup.com/poll/248837/church-membership-down-sharply-past-two-decades.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/248837/church-membership-down-s...
- wahnfrieden 5y agoIt pairs well with Mark Fisher
- mbrudd 5y agoFisher's Capitalist Realism is a must-read!
- ivarv 5y agoI'm looking forward to reading this. I listened to this excellent podcast with David Graber's coauthor, David Wengrow about the book and the fascinating discussion really hints that this will be a good read. https://srslywrong.com/podcast/242-the-dawn-of-the-dawn-of-everything-w-david-wengrow https://srslywrong.com/podcast/242-the-dawn-of-the-dawn-of-e...
- grugq 5y agoCurrently reading it. I recommend “Against the Grain” and also “Pre Industrial Societies.” They give a really good perspective on human life and the structures we create. One of my favourite quotes is: the hallmarks of a state: appropriation, inequality and hierarchy. Grains are the only agricultural product that can grow an early state, because it can be easily taxed, it’s fungible so you can pay with it, and people can’t run off with their field and canals to somewhere else. It’s kind of a wonderful point that without the taxman there would be no civilisation.
- alecst 5y agoI'm interested in anything that tears Sapiens apart, partly because I loved that book so much and need something to temper my enthusiasm.
- willowfine 5y agoTry Ridley’s The Rational Optimist, as I mentioned above.
- wahnfrieden 5y agoYou will have a taste for it within the first 2-3 chapters, it engages with the colonialist legacy that led to Sapiens and other similar works from the start