7 ms·
The Risk of Vaccinated Covid Transmission Is Not Low
- rogerkirkness 5y agoIt is mind blowing that people thought it reduces transmission more than a little bit. If you read studies about intramuscular vaccines, it is clear they do not prevent spread of aerosol viruses. Nasally administered vaccines do, much more so. If you want to prevent spread of an aerosol virus with a vaccine, use nasal application. It costs a bit more and is harder to ship, but works.
- miles 5y ago> It is mind blowing that people thought it reduces transmission more than a little bit. It's official: Vaccinated people don't transmit COVID-19 https://fortune.com/2021/04/01/its-official-vaccinated-people-dont-transmit-covid-19/ https://fortune.com/2021/04/01/its-official-vaccinated-peopl... > "Our data from the CDC today suggests that vaccinated people do not carry the virus, don't get sick, and that it's not just in the clinical trials but it's also in real-world data," CDC Director Dr. Rochelle Walensky told Rachel Maddow on Monday, March 29.
- dredmorbius 5y agoScience is evidence based. Evidence changes with experience and time. Evidence is subject to errors in method and interpretation. With luck, those are also corrected with time. What science does not do is choose some ideologically convenient belief, then selectively cherry-pick and selectively ignore evidence or arguments to buttress that. At the very top of the article you link is this note: Since CDC Director Rochelle Walensky made the comments discussed below, scientists have pushed back against the idea that vaccinated people “don’t carry the virus.” We've published a deeper analysis of the debate here. That is: there is disagreement over the evidence. The upshot of the announcement, in April of 2021, was this: [T]he most important part of the recent CDC findings is that vaccinated people are very unlikely to suffer asymptomatic SARS-CoV-2 infections. Participants in the study who were fully vaccinated with the Pfizer-BioNTech or Moderna vaccines were 90% less likely to be infected with SARS-CoV-2. Of infections that did occur, only 10.7 percent were asymptomatic. Taken together, this means vaccinated people are highly unlikely to transmit the virus when they are not suffering symptoms. This also means that as vaccination rates continue to rise, the virus will have fewer and fewer possible hosts. Again, highlighted at the very top of the article you've selected to link here. You've chosen to highlight the headline, which was not selected by the CDC and may well not have been selected by the authors either. (Traditional practice is that headlines are written by a headlines editor, more recently, headlines are often selected by A/B testing for impact, clicks, and engagement.) Moreover, the point made gets to another complaint that's been raised repeatedly by the antiempirical crowd: why should vaccinated people need to wear masks if vaccines protect against transmitting or receiving the virus? What we've learned since this announcement and piece is that even if vaccinated there remain both transmission and infection risks. Vaccines are not some majickal warding spell, but are simply a technological tool that leverages the body's own immune defences. Sometimes more effectively than others. And I very strongly suspect that you either know all of this, or have chosen deliberately not to based on your submission and comment history.
- rogerkirkness 5y agoPeople think that vaccines are like force fields but it's more like better training and weapons. The vaccine does not affect how many soldiers land on your beaches, they affect how timely and effective your response is. Intramuscular vaccines do not do much to prevent replication of proteins in your nasal cavities, where as nasally adminsitered vaccines do much more so. So by population vaccinating people with intramuscular vaccines, we have reduced harm significantly, but we have not meaningfully affected the virus ability to spread.
- nojokes 5y agoIt has reduced the transmission way more than a little bit. It depends on the viral load you are being it with and your antibody levels. mRNA vaccines are able to induce antibodies in mucus but you are right, nasal vaccines MIGHT do better and I wish there is more focus on developing them.
- darthrupert 5y agoIt is absolutely baffling that people plain refuse to understand that getting a disease is a prerequisite for spreading a disease. Therefore, it is crystal clear that vaccinations help reducing the spread of the virus. As long as we are in the topic of conspiracies, how about the idea that the original spreader of the virus (China) and its allies is making it worse by spreading seriously harmful misinformation in English?
- a0-prw 5y agoHere are some numbers from Denmark covering Omicron infections: About 90% of positive PCR tests are in fully vaccinated (double or triple). About 8.5% are in unvaccinated. About 75% of the population is fully vaccinated. About 24% is unvaccinated. Why are the unvaccinated underrepresented in Omicron infections? Source: https://www.dr.dk/nyheder/indland/status-paa-coronavirus-lige-nu https://www.dr.dk/nyheder/indland/status-paa-coronavirus-lig...
- GuB-42 5y agoA few hypothesis, in order of preference: - Most of the infections come from "superspreader" events such as large gatherings where vaccination is mandatory - Children, who make most of the unvaccinated, are less affected - Vaccinated cases are detected earlier, possibly because they get symptoms earlier - Delta outcompetes omicron among people with no immunity
- gorjusborg 5y agoBeing emphatic (or baffled) doesn't make your beliefs correct. In case you are just uninformed, lookup 'Typhoid Mary' for a famous example of an asymptomatic carrier of disease. Just because you aren't showing symptoms or dying doesn't mean you can't spread disease. That said, I'm not making a claim contrary to yours. But your claim seems based more on your intuition than on fact or history.
- rogerkirkness 5y agoYou clearly have not read much biology - this disease is a symptom of the presence of problematic protein entering people's body through their nose. The virus can replicate and spread from your nose without becoming symptomatic or spreading to other systems. Intramuscular vaccines do not prevent replication of proteins in your nasal passage, which is how covid spreads. Vaccines prevent symptomatic disease in most cases for most variants prior to omicron. Nasal administered vaccines like radvac still for work this reason.
- xvector 5y agoMy biggest fear is an antivaxxer taking up an ER bed someone else might need for a real issue. IMO antivaxxers should be denied admission to a full ER for COVID-related morbidities if they have not taken the vaccine. If they would like to make the bodily choice of not getting the vaccine, they can also make the bodily choice of not getting emergency treatment. At some point a line has to be drawn. When resources are low, care should be prioritized amongst those that will make the most of it, or rather - those that won't spit in its face.
- timbo1642 5y ago
- rogerkirkness 5y agoOmicron is much less likely to hospitalize people, it never reached a concerning level in South Africa and cases are falling fast. I could see wanting covid patients to pay for it themselves, but denying them entry is ridiculously cruel.
- xvector 5y agoWhat is cruel, is not doing the bare minimum as a member of society and needlessly taking up precious ER resources that other responsible and well-meaning members of society might need. To clarify, rather than denial of entry, I am suggesting deprioritization in the ER. If someone got into a car crash tomorrow and the ER is full, given a similar expected mortality between the crash victim and antivaxxer, the antivaxxer should be ejected to make room. Today we are already seeing that antivaxxers are saturating ERs and people have to wait hours for serious issues. I do not think it is particularly controversial to say that the antivaxxer is less deserving of care.
- iab 5y agoWhether people agree with you or not isn't the real issue here IMO. If this approach were to be adopted, it would be up to the physicians and other front-line workers to make the prioritization call, which adds too much of a burden to them.
- nkurz 5y agoIf I could do things over again, I would not have allowed my son to be around even vaccinated people indoors without masks. If her goal is to completely protect her son from contracting Covid, I find it surprising that she'd allow him to be in contact with any potentially infected people at all. Is it really the case that an infected person can be rendered completely safe by a typical mask? Are there studies that quantify the reduction of risk for different types of masks worn by a infected person?
- josephcsible 5y agoSo why do people still have to show their papers when they walk into buildings?
- zaik 5y ago> Once infected, vaccinated people seem to transmit COVID similarly to unvaccinated people There's are very important conditional here.
- falamboram 5y agoThe vaccines do prevent infection with covid in the majority of cases. If you get it you spread it at a similar rate, but the vaccine does prevent you from getting it in the first place.
- nojokes 5y agoBased on the current evidence, you will also most likely spread it less. The difference is not huge but is there.
- anramon 5y ago>rather than relying only on news reports, I dug into the science myself I think this is the most important phrase in the entire article, we know how untrustable is news reporting, specially when talking science, and specially when talking about government agenda.