4 ms·
Since we're offering anecdotes, I spent some significant money (considering that we're talking about light bulbs here) to switch over to CFLs a few years ago.
by ams6110 15y ago
Since we're offering anecdotes, I spent some significant money (considering that we're talking about light bulbs here) to switch over to CFLs a few years ago. It was a disaster. Most lasted less than a year. Two (out of an original 20 or so) are still working.
I'm stockpiling incandescents so I can wait and see if the LED technology proves itself in the real world.
- TheCondor 15y agoCan you mention the brand of the CFLs? I switched over just about every bulb in my house 4 years ago. For most I got the 100watt ones from Costco, I honestly don't remember the exact brand name it is electralux or something like that. I've replaced one of them. We have about 20 of those conical lights in recessed fixtures, I converted those to the ones from Home Depot. I've replaced 2 of those. The only really noticable thing I've noticed is that they take time to load which I actually sort of like in the early morning, they start a little bit more dim and after about 2 minutes reach maximum brightness. The cone ones have some sort of "yellow light" filter on them so it's not surgical room bright white. There are two lamps with kind of a crappy lampshade that seem maybe un-naturally white and bright but otherwise we've been really happy. I did two outdoor lights and they're working great too, this is in Colorado and they've operated in temperatures from negative 20 to about 100, still seem to work fine after 3 years. I've heard the horror stories about spending $150 on lightbulbs only to have crappy light and having to replace a bunch of brokens but I haven't had that experience. Not sure if it's a brand issue or dirty power or something else.
- atourgates 15y agoI don't argue that early CFL's had big problems, but I'd seriously encourage you to try again. First, they're quite cheap. Assuming you don't need dimmable CFL's, you can get them for less than $1/bulb. With my utility's incentive programs (Southern California Edison), I often see 60W replacements for ~$0.20/bulb. Second, they've gotten quite a bit better. Less buzzing, less failure and an overall better quality of light.
- tomjen3 15y agoThing is there is no reason to change lightbulb technology the old bulbs worked perfectly. So when new bulbs are put on the market it isn't unrealistic to expect them to work as least aswell as the ones they are supposed to replace. When they fail to do that, why should we risk even more money just because thay are supposed to be less bad now.
- atourgates 15y agoNo reason? Only if you don't care about your energy bill. Running a 60W light bulb for 6-hours a day for a year costs - in California - $18.25. Multiply that by, I donno, 5 bulbs in your house and you're spending $91.25/yr on your lighting. If you replace those 5 60W bulbs with 13W CFL's, and your cost is just $21.90/yr for the same amount of light. Even including the cost of buying 5 new CFL bulbs, and ignoring the cost of replacing your incandescent lights, you're going to save ~$65 in energy savings just the 1st year.
- tomjen3 15y agoWhich is shit for nothing when you compare it with the cost of gas, rent or (and this particulary irks me: food). I run only the bulb in the room I am in, which means i would save less than 20$/year which is less than my low care limit. Add the shit lighting early bulb death and possibility of mercury poisoning my room (you are supposed to leave for half an hour after you drop one, then clean up with heavy gloves) and replacing the bulb goes from an economically decent idea to something less than attractive.
- tomjen3 15y agoThing is there is no reason to change lightbulb technology the old bulbs worked perfectly. So when new bulbs are put on the market it isn't unrealistic to expect them to work as least aswell as the ones they are supposed to replace. When they fail to do that, why should we risk even more money just because thay are supposed to be less bad now.
- tomjen3 15y ago
- tsotha 15y agoI had a similar experience, but one thing I noticed was the fixture mattered a whole lot because heat shortens the CFL lifespan considerably. The ones that last the longest were the old-style end table lamps (with lampshades) with a single vertical socket and plenty of airflow. The worst are multi-socket horizontal fixtures with no airflow. The newer bulbs are definitely better, but they still don't last long in the wrong kind of fixture, and if that's the kind of fixture you have you're better off just buying incandescents.