3 ms·
> Does it really matter how much more harm it causes? Yes, the quantity and quality are the most important part of this whole discussion. Anyone should have a
by kelseyfrog 5y ago
> Does it really matter how much more harm it causes?
Yes, the quantity and quality are the most important part of this whole discussion. Anyone should have a handle on these before drawing conclusions that intend to reduce harm. I'll make an analogy. How many times have you had to remind someone to profile before making optimizations? Studying harm is the profiling and making changes to reduce it is optimizing.
> Why would you assume I have not?
That's fantastic! What did they say about this?
> There is literally no medical condition out there that is treated this way.
There's literally no medical condition that intersects society this way. Why apply a blanket approach to all medical conditions?
> looking at each case individually seems kinda middle ground to me.
It sounds nice, but the outcome is that individual practitioners will exert their individual biases[1]. This is why we have things like DSM[2] in psychology, and in this specific case WPATH[3].
1. Don't mistake this that my goal is zero biases. We're talking about reducing harm, not eliminating it. Let's not let perfect be the enemy of good.
2. An example of standards
3. https://www.wpath.org/publications/soc https://www.wpath.org/publications/soc
- noxer 5y agoI said "Does it really matter how much MORE harm it causes?" Context matters. The question was "does it matter if its 5% more or 10% more? (or any other number more)" The answer is: No, it does not matter, because its more and we want less. You dont do something because it "only" 5% worse and stop if its 10% worse. You dont need to know how much worse it is. If its worse its worse. If it cause preventable collateral damage then its not okay to do it anyway.