6 ms·
Or you could see it as operating in the EU is a liability. If you don't handle data in just the way they like they will come after you.
by charcircuit 5y ago
Or you could see it as operating in the EU is a liability. If you don't handle data in just the way they like they will come after you.
- arlcode 5y agoSure, like any law in any place. EU member states and representatives decided that not having certain business models is preferably. Them leaving the single market is a welcome result.
- darkwater 5y agoWe can live without data hoarding companies, thanks.
- jacquesm 5y agoThe EU is merely leading the way here, you can expect all of the developed world to have similar data protection laws on the books sooner or later. And if you think that treating data in the proper way is hard then you probably shouldn't be in business at all. Operating in the EU is not a liability if you treat your users data in a respectful and responsible way. Common sense alone would answer your questions on what is and what isn't allowed in the vast majority of the cases. That this doesn't align with the free-for-all that was the WWW for the first two and a half decades doesn't change that, morality isn't all that hard and each and every company that crosses those lines is very much aware of it. These are not accidental misinterpretations of the law by any stretch of the imagination, they are wilful abuse.
- KronisLV 5y ago> The EU is merely leading the way here, you can expect all of the developed world to have similar data protection laws on the books sooner or later. While i do believe in being privacy conscious, i don't believe that this will be the case anytime soon (or at least until a generational shift happens). No business is interested in having to suddenly comply with such regulations and essentially no longer being able to utilize the data of individuals however they please. Ergo, corporate interests will probably lead to lots of lobbying in this regard, just look at what happened with net neutrality and the advertising around it. > Operating in the EU is not a liability if you treat your users data in a respectful and responsible way. I think that all of this boils down to profit margins and viewing people as just numbers on a sheet somewhere, to extract wealth from. Just look at how scummy many of the cookie banner implementations are, designers being paid to implement as many dark patterns as possible, at least up until lawsuits started.
- jacquesm 5y agoThink of it as the law catching up with technology. > No business is interested in having to suddenly comply with such regulations and essentially no longer being able to utilize the data of individuals however they please. Indeed, hence the need for regulation. > Ergo, corporate interests will probably lead to lots of lobbying in this regard, just look at what happened with net neutrality and the advertising around it. Sure. But since EU citizens will be enjoying those protections and US citizens will not eventually this will translate into an advantage for companies doing business from the EU and into the US. For that reason alone there will be a big incentive for the US to make a law that is symmetrical to remove this advantage. > I think that all of this boils down to profit margins and viewing people as just numbers on a sheet somewhere, to extract wealth from. This is a big factor, but not the only factor: data that is in isolation worthless can become very valuable or even dangerous when combined with other worthless or innocent data. There are plenty of examples of this. The balance clearly lies in protecting consumers from the fall-out of these and the more purposeful abuses. This is a matter of raising consciousness about what rights you already have, not necessarily of giving you new ones. > Just look at how scummy many of the cookie banner implementations are, designers being paid to implement as many dark patterns as possible, at least up until lawsuits started. Agreed. The EU did the right thing with the GDPR, it laid bare how many companies were outright scandalous in how they were dealing with the data that they were entrusted with, they were bad stewards and it is good to see this level of enforcement because that means that companies will wise up to it and find better - and cleaner - ways of monetizing their products and services. Once they have those they will realize that regulatory capture can be theirs if they lobby for these rights to be extended to everybody. The EU is too large a market to miss out on.
- Nextgrid 5y ago> since EU citizens will be enjoying those protections and US citizens will not eventually this will translate into an advantage for companies doing business from the EU and into the US. For that reason alone there will be a big incentive for the US to make a law that is symmetrical to remove this advantage. Given the lack of similar regulation in the US despite the situation being so bad that unsolicited spam subsidises the postal service and that even government agencies sell user data I’m not sure there is a desire for this from the general population. It doesn’t help that politicians rely on a lot of what would breach the GDPR to help their reelection such as targeted advertising and unsolicited (and often misleading - pretending to be written by the official itself) email and phone campaigns.
- Mirioron 5y agoHow are websites and apps going to make money though? Like it or not, the reason the internet became this popular is because of all the free stuff on it. If everything was behind subscription fees it possibly would never have taken off. I don't think I would've ever used Google if they had charged a fee for the service. This would effectively make political interests entrenched even more on the internet, because they'll see it as worthwhile to make free services. They get to feed you politically slanted ideas - just like free political newspapers. >Operating in the EU is not a liability if you treat your users data in a respectful and responsible way. Common sense alone would answer your questions on what is and what isn't allowed in the vast majority of the cases. Relying on common sense is playing with fire. Common sense says that with this many people using the services of these companies that people are okay with what these companies are doing. That's not what GDPR says and that's not something I had any vote on or anything like that. You might prefer the cable TV model, but I prefer YouTube. I like that I don't have to pay anything to go look at a large variety of topics. Far more than any paid service would ever provide.
- jacquesm 5y agoAdvertising worked fine before tracking. Selling your users data, especially this kind of data is a thing that more than negates the value your users derived from your service, in some places it might get you killed. There are many ways for websites and apps to make money, and if you can't then maybe you simply shouldn't.
- Mirioron 5y agoAdvertising without tracking doesn't work. Only a small set of businesses can really advertise online without tracking. Any business that is in a specific area or doesn't use English will find it a bad deal, because most of their ads will be shown to people who don't understand the language or aren't in the area. Even with tracking ads get the language component wrong frequently. Unskippable ads in a language you can't understand is even worse than normal.
- jacquesm 5y ago
- charcircuit 5y ago>And if you think that treating data in the proper way is hard then you probably shouldn't be in business at all. The EUs definition of the proper way isn't a universal definition and it conflicts with the way I view that data should be treated.
- jacquesm 5y agoHow you view it is irrelevant: it's the law.
- breakfastduck 5y agoWhat aspect of GDPR is troublesome to you? Because 'dont abuse your ownership of personal data' is pretty much what it boils down to.
- charcircuit 5y ago>What aspect of GDPR is troublesome to you? It tries to restrict data. Information wants to be free. It has no owner.
- jacquesm 5y agoWhat is this, Slashdot ca 1996? Private information in fact does have an owner: the user that it reflects on.
- charcircuit 5y agoOnce you share information it is no longer private unless you put that person under an NDA or something similar. If you meant personal information then that doesn't make sense either. No one owns the fact that George Washington was male. It is just a statement that could be true or false. George Washington has no control over me spreading this information. Especially since he is dead.
- jacquesm 5y agoYou have a completely unique idea about the meaning of 'privacy', you may want to adjust your definition to the one that the rest of the world works so that we can have meaningful conversations. George Washington's gender is of no consideration whatsoever in this discussion, so bringing it up is a variation on the theme of the strawman.
- charcircuit 5y ago>You have a completely unique idea about the meaning of 'privacy' I used the word private, but not privacy. I'm not 100% sure what you are getting at. >so bringing it up is a variation on the theme of the strawman. It was an example of data pertaining to someone. I brought it up since I didn't think the word private made sense.
- michaelbuckbee 5y agoI feel that "just the way they like" is honestly a pretty low bar to clear and in general are common sense and respectful things that you should be doing with user data in the first place. - Tell people up front what you will do with their data - Let them opt out - Track what services your own service uses (Ex: your website -> google analytics) - If people want to know what data you have about them tell them - If people want you to delete their data (and there is no legal obligation to keep it) delete their data - Take reasonable steps to keep user data safe In this case Grindr was passing (per the article): advertising ID, IP address, GPS, location, gender, age, device information and app name to a bunch of Ad Services with "no control". So beyond just "handling data" Grindr was getting paid (ads) for sharing your data to companies that could then also turn around and do whatever they wanted with that data.
- charcircuit 5y ago>common sense and respectful things that you should be doing with user data in the first place It's disrespectful to be nosey into what people are doing or to give them orders on what they can or can't do. >So beyond just "handling data" Grindr was getting paid (ads) for sharing your data to companies that could then also turn around and do whatever they wanted with that data. Good on them. They figured out a way to make money using information that they collected.
- netizen-936824 5y ago>It's disrespectful to be nosey into what people are doing >Good on them. They figured out a way to make money using information that they collected. These two statements don't jive. Its disrespectful to be nosey, but its fine if people buy data and be nosey into other peoples lives? That's quite absurd
- charcircuit 5y ago>These two statements don't jive. The first statement is about a user being nosey into what a company does with the data. There is an expectation for dating services to collect data like age, gender, etc about a user. I wouldn't really call them nosey. Since it's kind of expected for them to get that information from you. Is a dentist being nosey if they ask for your dental history?
- denton-scratch 5y agoGDPR enforcement is pretty gentle. For the first offence you will just get a warning. Grindr's fine is a warning that you should heed such warnings. Yes, operating in the EU is a liability; operating anywhere that has laws is a liability. And the risks of operating somewhere that doesn't have laws is an even greater liability.