7 ms·
The Future of Light is the LED
- onemoreact 15y agoI often wonder about these types of regulations. I would much rather see a 1$/bulb tax on incandescent bulbs drive people to more efficient solutions when it's reasonable to do so. So, if I want a 150watt light for my attic that is on for 15 hours a year then there is no reason to go with LED's at the same time I am now much better off using an LED for kitchen lighting. Does anyone know why such things are so rarely used?
- Symmetry 15y agoBecause then it would be a tax. Also, we couldn't have the warm fuzzies of having 100% conversion to CFL/LEDs, 99.5% might have the same practical effect, but it doesn't have the same rhetorical force.
- Someone 15y agoI do not know whether to remove only the parentheses, or also the text fragments inside them to get closest to the truth, but I think this changeover is not (only) optimized for the short-term good of consumers. It (also) is optimized for the good of lightbulb producers. They want a fast transition, so that they can scale up production fast. Regulations that forbid production and/or sale of old-style bulbs make such a scale up easier for them. Enforcing a fast change also may have a net positive effect when looking at the entire transition period.
- tomjen3 15y agoBecause politicians want power and there is no power in letting people decide for themselves what they want to do. It isn't going to save me money though, because i am going for the halogen bulbs which save only 30% and then buying those that are a bit more powerful than the bulbs they will replace (ie 40 gets reålaced by a sixty). Fuck politicians.
- colanderman 15y agoThe demo as described is kind of silly… it's easy to get two bulbs to appear to generate the same color white light reflecting off a given background; there are at most 4-5 variables to adjust (given that humans have 4-5 different classes of light sensors). A group of 5 LEDs (red, yellow, green, aqua, blue) could be made to pass this test but would render colors terribly. Color me impressed when participants can't tell the difference between rainbows generated by each light passing through a prism – that would be a much better test of color rendering ability.
- spython 15y agoTo test the color rendering ability just take a CD or a DVD disc, and hold it to the light. On CFLs you'll often see just a few streaks instead of a rainbow, while halogen lamps and LEDs are pretty good.
- colanderman 15y agoThanks, that's a good tip. I'm surprised that all my CFLs (even ones with supposedly good CRI) show up as red, green, and blue blotches...
- achille 15y agoI'm surprised behind the huge push behind a "soft yellow" colored bulb. The articles makes a claim that humans prefer the yellow/orange glow due to prevalence of fire as lighting. But I don't see a single mention of the color termperature of pure sunshine, which is much, much closer to pure white (5500K). Flourescent bulbs that glow at 5500K are considered "pure white" [0] and seem to be demonized in the article as too harsh. I think this is a case of old folks that grew up under incandescents and prefer them purely because they grew up with it. As Steve Jobs has mentioned [1] (about keyboards), we just need to wait for them to die out eventually. [0] http://www.pse.com/savingsandenergycenter/ForHomes/PublishingImages/CFLchart2_176x208.jpg http://www.pse.com/savingsandenergycenter/ForHomes/Publishin... [1] http://orangejuiceliberationfront.com/theyll-die-out-eventually http://orangejuiceliberationfront.com/theyll-die-out-eventua...
- nostromo 15y agoI like the sun just fine -- when I'm outside during the day. However, the color of light is important to the human sleep cycle. If you fill your house with sun (blue) colored lights, you're going to shift your melatonin production later and may have a hard time going to sleep. Humans have evolved with blue light during the day and yellow light at night for quite some time, so I think it's more than just a nostalgic preference. From "Effect of Illuminance and Color Temperature on Lowering of Physiological Activity": "...we surmise that the effect of color temperature is greater than that of illuminance in an ordinary residential bedroom or similar environment where a lowering of physiological activity is desirable, and we therefore find the use of low color temperature illumination more important than the reduction of illuminance. Subjective drowsiness results also indicate that reduction of illuminance without reduction of color temperature should be avoided." http://www.jstage.jst.go.jp/article/ahs/18/4/18_117/_article/-char/en http://www.jstage.jst.go.jp/article/ahs/18/4/18_117/_article... This is why I use Flux on my Mac: http://stereopsis.com/flux/ http://stereopsis.com/flux/
- ntoshev 15y agoI think the reason fluorescent lightning looks bad is not the color temperature, it's the narrow spectrum of emitted light.
- Lagged2Death 15y agoI've been as frustrated as anyone with CFL bulbs that die early deaths, but I think this article is more than a little over-the-top with the CFL bashing. None of the CFLs in my house are "horrible, flickery, ugly." Many of them have lasted for years and put out light that's indistinguishable from incandescents. Still and all, I'm glad to see something even better on the way.
- ajanuary 15y agoA lot of people seem biased against them from poor early examples. They've gotten a lot better.
- oinksoft 15y agoThe ones I've tried still make a terrible humming noise much like a fluorescent bulb in a ballast, and cast a somewhat pinkish light. They also don't fit well in fixtures designed for incandescent bulbs, sticking out at the end (looking at a bare lightbulb is no fun for the eyes). I really want to like CFLs but with all of these disadvantages and how much more difficult they are to safely dispose of than a plain incandescent, I still haven't switched.
- stan_rogers 15y agoThe form factor (for some applications) is a genuine problem, but it's the only remaining problem in my recent experience. There is a reasonable facsimile of a 60-100W "A" bulb for use with lamp shades that clip onto the bulb, but the base widens too abruptly for some fixtures, and low-wattage bulbs do tend to be longer than their incandescent counterparts. I'm not using any "name" bulbs (except in photo lighting, which is another kettle of fish entirely) at the moment (they're the cheapies from Canadian Tire) and it has been a long time since I've experienced mechanical noise, flicker or an unacceptable spectrum (there are only a few very small gaps, as revealed by a diffraction spectrometer -- er, a CD held at an angle, which has served me well as a photographer over the years). And "pinkish" is weird -- it sounds like somebody's tried to use older "conventional" phosphors (which gave a very green-biased spectrum) and tried to overcompensate with the complement (magenta). I've never run into that with any of the brands I've tried (and I'm rather picky). ADDED: the buzzing shouldn't be a problem with a recent bulb, either. That's an artifact of an older ballast design that I haven't seen used in years. All of the ones I've tried in the last five years or so have had high-frequency ballasts and long-decay phosphors to deal with the flicker issue (it's not an issue anymore), so the 120Hz buzz went away at the same time.
- torstesu 15y agoIn countries or areas with a cold climate the argument of energy conversion is less significant as most of the energy consumption is used for heat anyway. To those advocating that LED bulbs will last longer, you might find this interesting: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phoebus_cartel http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phoebus_cartel
- ars 15y agoLess, maybe. But no place is cold for the entire year, the heat is generated in poor places (for example if you have cans all the heat is generated above the insulation, which is pointless). And electric heat is much less efficient than natural gas.
- sbierwagen 15y agoAnd electric heat is much less efficient than natural gas. Less efficient per dollar, depending on the cost of electricity and natural gas. Electric heat is, of course, 100% thermodynamically "efficient", since all the power eventually ends up as heat. With natural gas, you have to pipe the exhaust outside, and you lose a small amount of heat that way.
- ars 15y agoIs there a reason you are ignoring transmission and generation losses? By your standard natural gas is also 100% thermodynamically efficient - all of it ends up as heat. Some of it outdoors, sure, but that is true for electric heat as well. Those thin electric lines outside your house get pretty hot.
- sbierwagen 15y agoIs there a reason you are ignoring transmission and generation losses for natural gas? Methane isn't a frictionless fluid, it costs real money to pump it through pipelines. And, of course, you have to dig it out of the ground in the first place.
- 15y ago
- sbierwagen 15y agoOh boy, I do love reading an article in Wired about a field I specialize in. It just makes me so amazingly happy. 1.) Wired sure does love yellow light! Kinda odd, since this is a magazine that is, ostensibly, about modern technology; unlike say, Good Old Days.[1] What they smoothly elide is that the sensitivity of the human eye peaks at 555 nanometers. (green)[2] The more red you have in your white light spectrum, the less efficient the lamp is. This is a hard physical limit. No amount of cleverness will get around it-- the eye just isn't as sensitive to red light. The warmer the light, the less efficient your bulb will be. 2700K (warm-white) is pretty bad. 5500K (pure white) is okay. 7000K would be ideal, but I don't think anybody actually makes lamps with a color temperature[3] that high. 2.) ...Additional colors and increased brightness required more nuanced control of layer composition and depth. Modern LED makers accomplish this by using precise ratios of indium, gallium, aluminum, and nitrogen for the crystal layer, which results in a bluish color. But on their own, not even advanced LEDs can produce anything suitable for the living room. The blue-tinged illumination is fine for, say, a pen flashlight on a keychain, but it doesn’t come close to the warm light the human eye desires. So the LEDs found in current household applications are blue diodes daubed with a powdered coating called a phosphor, which includes rare-earth elements that filter blue light. Not wrong so much as massively, massively misleading. Early white LEDs were also phosphor laminated, because LEDs are monochromatic devices. There's no way to get broad-spectrum light out of them otherwise. These phosphors, by the way, are the same coatings that produce the "awful, sickly" light in the CFLs Dan hates so much. LED phosphors run off of blue light, not ultraviolet, but the principle is the same. --- 1: Actual magazine, that actually exists. http://www.goodolddaysmagazine.com/ http://www.goodolddaysmagazine.com/ 2: https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Luminous_efficacy https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Luminous_effi... 3: https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Color_temperature https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Color_tempera...
- ender7 15y agoHowever, their pseudo-scientific mumbo-jumbo about "what the eye desires" aside, Wired is right that people hate non-yellow light. Hate. This is a hard psychological limit. No amount of energy efficiency will get around it. If you make LED lighting, it must reproduce the color profile that people are used to from incandescent bulbs.
- tomjen3 15y agoI hope not. I spend a fortune on an led bulb a half or so year ago. Not only was the light so bad my desk looked like the inside of a morque, but as the sun went down I discovered that the light it did send out was so weak that I could't see anything. One expensive lesson later and I am not going to be using anything like an led again. I had planed to stay with the good old fashioned lightbulb (I can afford the bill) but the ever meddlesome lawmakers made those illegal to import.
- elangoc 15y agoEver since I heard about "dirty energy" emitted from CFL bulbs, I've become wary of fluorescent bulbs and pro-LCD bulbs. Especially because I'm an asthmatic: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VS5ogZxoZ2Y http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VS5ogZxoZ2Y http://www.magdahavas.com/2009/12/05/gs-units-explained/ http://www.magdahavas.com/2009/12/05/gs-units-explained/ Can anyone with more knowledge on the subject verify if the dirty energy info about CFL bulbs is true, and if LCD bulbs will be free from that?
- ugh 15y agoI really wouldn’t worry about “dirty energy”. There is likely no effect at all, any effects you might perceive are probably psychosomatic. Here is a study looking into health effects of electromagnetic fields: http://www.nap.edu/catalog.php?record_id=5155 http://www.nap.edu/catalog.php?record_id=5155 Here is another study looking at people suffering from electromagnetic sensitivity: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?Db=pubmed&Cmd=ShowDetailView&TermToSearch=9817951&ordinalpos=9&itool=EntrezSystem2.PEntrez.Pubmed.Pubmed_ResultsPanel.Pubmed_RVDocSum http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?Db=pubmed&Cmd=S... And another one: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?Db=pubmed&Cmd=ShowDetailView&TermToSearch=15832334&ordinalpos=2&itool=EntrezSystem2.PEntrez.Pubmed.Pubmed_ResultsPanel.Pubmed_RVDocSum http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?Db=pubmed&Cmd=S...
- espressodude 15y agoI'm not really that 'light' savvy but this seems good. It's like the transition from horses to automobiles.