5 ms·
> What is it about Apple that makes them hard to leave? It's a weird phenomenon. I don't use Apple devices, but my wife does. When she got into photography, I
by BeetleB 5y ago
> What is it about Apple that makes them hard to leave?
It's a weird phenomenon.
I don't use Apple devices, but my wife does. When she got into photography, I asked several tech forums as well as photography forums if there was an equivalent of Rapid Photo Downloader[1] for Macs. It's a nice Linux program that lets you conveniently rename images you're transferring from your camera, and put them in a folder that follows some rule you define. Nothing complex.
The responses I got just drove me nuts. Universally I was told I was doing it all wrong. I should use the standard Mac way of doing things. I forget the details, but it was basically "Let the standard Mac app import it into its library."
Well, where in the HD are the files, so we can do backups?
"You don't need to know that. Just let iCloud handle it."
What if I don't want to use iCloud?
No good responses to that other than "Why wouldn't you use iCloud?"
My wife wanted to use Darktable which wasn't inherently aware of the Mac way of doing things and insisted on simple folders and files. The responses I got were:
"You can export from the Mac app to a folder, and then point Darktable to it. Then when Darktable exports to JPEG, make sure you import the output files back into the Mac app."
But wouldn't that consume double the space?
"Yes."
When I explained that wasn't a viable option, I got a lot of hate.
And everyone told me setting up a folder/file structure for photos was Wrong and I didn't get the Mac way of doing things.
Now I'm sure there are simple ways of doing what I wanted on Macs. What surprised me was how much push back I was getting, and how even otherwise tech savvy folks (e.g. who know Linux quite well) couldn't answer my basic questions.
Reminded me of an Oakland cult[2] where the cult had set up their own parallel institutions that handled everything for its members (banks, paying bills, groceries, etc). They lived right in the city - not in a remote land they purchased, but the cult members had no idea how to function with the rest of society. People who decided to leave the cult had no idea how to pay electric bills or do banking.
[1] https://damonlynch.net/rapid/ https://damonlynch.net/rapid/
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Your_Black_Muslim_Bakery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Your_Black_Muslim_Bakery
- ur-whale 5y agoI am 100% with you, but you seem to miss some key points: 1. the vast majority of people do not understand how computers work: I have met many folks in both my personal and work life that do not understand *what a file is*, much less a directory (folder). 2. This whole notion of "where things are stored on the computer" is completely alien to most folks. As a matter of fact, this notion has been shoved down the throat of all Android / iOS user since inception of the ecosystems. I have found myself in a situation where I was unable to retrieve actual data I own stored on my own Android device because I made the mistake of storing it there *before* rooting the damn thing. 3. most people in the above category actively *do not* want to understand how computers work. Hence the "you don't get the mac way of doing things" comment you got. The fact that they completely hand over control over their information to Apple and are thereby imprisoned in the ecosystem and become hostages forever is completely lost on them.
- BeetleB 5y agoYour comment is valid about the average user. My comment made it quite clear I was not asking that category. These were not people who did not understand what files/folders where. They very clearly did. Even the least technically competent Windows users I've known understand files and folders. People who are primarily smartphone users - your statement is quite on point there.
- skinnymuch 5y agoThose people likely barely understood many concepts. I’d never think to seriously go to an Apple centric bigger forums. Unless it’s specifically geeky and into being able to manage things with automation, scripting, CLI, power apps, etc, Apple communities generally give very little and weak info. Those pseudo power Apple Mac users are not that far from average users.
- sbuk 5y agoI'm not suggesting that the information that you provided is in anyway wrong or fraudulent, but I do have some observations. Firstly, and most importantly, what you have described is categorically not the "Apple" way of doing things. I'd also add expecting things to work identically between Linux/Windows/Mac is is a fools errand. Different design decisions are made for each environment. To the flow - Darktable, whilst a fine DAW, clearly lacks in certain features. It should be able to handle importing and renaming files to a standard file structure, including sane default folder names, etc. without the need for scripting. This is a flaw that I suggest you raise with the maintainers. I've never heard of the software that you/your wife is using to capture the images from the device, but a cursory Google search bought up some interesting results... DigiCam seems to be what you are looking for! It free (libre and beer), scriptable, and acts as a DAW should you need. Will it work like Rapid Photo Downloader? Probably not, but the maintainer of that software doesn't seem interested in supporting macOS, and that's fine. From the FAQ: Does it work on Windows or Mac? No. Theoretically it could be ported to both Mac and Windows with minimal effort. The one gotcha is getting gphoto2 to work effectively on Windows. It's GPL2 and the source code is here; nothing stopping you or your wife porting it to macOS. https://github.com/damonlynch/rapid-photo-downloader https://github.com/damonlynch/rapid-photo-downloader Finally, a bit about the "Cult". The Mac 'cult' is no different to the FOSS 'cult'. Both sides are enthusiastic about their environments to the point of the being, frankly, assholes. Too much "your doing it wrong" and not enough "what are you trying to do".
- BeetleB 5y ago> Firstly, and most importantly, what you have described is categorically not the "Apple" way of doing things. It's not clear from your comment if my insisting on using files/directories is not the Apple way of doing things, or what the people on Mac forums told me is not the Apple way of doing things. If the former, your whole comment merely adds to what I and my parent were trying to say - that even though MacOS has totally fine support for files/folders, Mac users appear to have a hard time switching away from Apple. As for the rest of your comment, I don't understand the relevance or why it is being directed to me. I'm not complaining that there doesn't seem to be an equivalent of Rapid Photo Downloader. I'm complaining that even highly technical MacOS users insist that resorting to basic things like storing photos in directories and dealing with their file names is simply wrong - and that their solution entails a lot more disk space and had no clear backup solution. > It should be able to handle importing and renaming files to a standard file structure, including sane default folder names, etc. without the need for scripting. This is a flaw that I suggest you raise with the maintainers. They are aware of it, and designed it intentionally this way for a good reason. They have certain goals, and this is explicitly not one of them. I can't fault them for not doing what they make clear they have no intention of doing. > Finally, a bit about the "Cult". The Mac 'cult' is no different to the FOSS 'cult'. Again, not sure why this is directed to me. I'm no fan of the FOSS/GNU/GPL cult either. The point I will make is that most Linux users are not members of those cults either, and it is not a barrier for them using Linux. The same goes for Windows. When I've wanted to do nonstandard things in Windows, I don't get Windows users telling me I'm doing it wrong.
- tomrod 5y agoThat's frankly crazy! Macs copied Unix systems, of which Linux is now the standard bearer. If Mac built their operating system correctly, it would be seamless for a Linux user to hop on modulo keyboard mappings (which, in my limited experience with Mac, hurts the muscle memory profoundly). Per your comment and my limited observations, it is clearly not seamless. What you described makes a lot of sense though. What you're describing is learned helplessness, which increases switching costs for the low-quintile technically inclined users.