9 ms·
Fast fashion is a root cause of a huge amount of fabric waste, plastic waste, and cost shifting of waste streams to developing nations. Not to say Shein isn't
by ggm 5y ago
Fast fashion is a root cause of a huge amount of fabric waste, plastic waste, and cost shifting of waste streams to developing nations.
Not to say Shein isn't responding well to an economic niche. Just, that it has an externalised cost: disposal of clothes on a fashion whim is not a good thing.
- xapata 5y agoLet's just tax carbon extraction and not worry about who's doing what with it. Although I suppose there's a separate externality to creating friable material. The issue of discarding too much should be addressed with higher prices at the dump.
- ggm 5y agoBottle and can recycling worked with incentives. But both are valuable to the receiver outside of the cash incentive on energy grounds. I don't think fabric recycling has that energy benefit so I am unsure incentives would work full life cycle. But you could be right: carbon pricing down to the edge on all things might actually be good economics if we can work out how to make it run. Please don't say blockchain
- IgorPartola 5y agoI have one better than blockchain. When can we all get those futuristic ones piece outfits with the lightning bolt across the torso? I was led to believe that’s what everyone would be wearing sooner or later.
- ggm 5y ago"Things to come" (1935) and "metropolis" (1927) said loincloths and Greek togas for elites but boilersuits for plebs. I would wear a spandex "onesie" with a lightning bolt.. for about 30 seconds.
- throwhauser 5y ago> I would wear a spandex "onesie" with a lightning bolt.. for about 30 seconds. Which brings us right back to (very) fast fashion.
- ggm 5y agoOK. Let's make one onesie, call it an NFT and you have to post a picture wearing it, before you pass it on to somebody else.
- bryanrasmussen 5y ago> I would wear a spandex "onesie" with a lightning bolt.. for about 30 seconds. sure - long enough for you to run around Central City robbing every bank.
- jjoonathan 5y agoDon't forget the underwear on the outside!
- Vetch 5y agoThe problem, not unique to fast fashion, is we've structured things such that recycling is rarely economical. That shouldn't be the case, our damage to ecosystems means prices are not properly accounting for the cost of negative externalities. Whether in inputs (unethical labor practices, questionable material composition, hazardous inputs handling, manipulative marketing tactics and artificial scarcity) or in outputs (planned obsolescence, unsustainable consumption, disposal, discounting full product life-cycle), socio+ecological costs are ignored to maximize profits while keeping prices fairly low. It's good to democratize access to more and fancier options but if this comes by cheating and a dishonest accounting of costs, it's not worth it (full cost accounting will be better in the long run, having to account for product full life cycle might spur investment and innovations in say, mechanical disposal automation or plasma arc gasification).
- einpoklum 5y agoThe assumption that social goals are achievable by price and tax adjustments is faulty. So is the assumption that the state = "us".
- xapata 5y agoL'etat c'est moi. Taxes (and thereby price adjustments) can achieve some social goals. Empirically so, not assumed. Both the "state" and "us" are social constructs, and are simultaneously both essentially the same concept and entirely separate concepts. The nice thing is that we don't need theory here, we can just try it and find out if it helps, then try something else if it fails.
- DFHippie 5y ago> Although I suppose there's a separate externality to creating friable material. The issue of discarding too much should be addressed with higher prices at the dump. If the dump costs more, people create unlicensed dumps. Thus the cost remains external.
- colinmhayes 5y agoThese goods are produced internationally. How do you intend to force foreign governments to have a carbon tax?
- ordx 5y agoImport tax
- colinmhayes 5y agoHow do you know how much carbon the goods used?
- usrusr 5y agoA valid question. By keeping to raise that import tax until they accept doing a trustable carbon tax instead. Next up: how could you identify a trustable carbon tax? How could you do the tariff thing without all hell breaking loose both on the level of inter-government relations and in terms of plain old grassroots contraband snuggling?
- WillPostForFood 5y agoSounds like it is true because of the word "fast" in fast fashion, but is it true? Is Shein really causing more fabric waste, plastic waste, and cost shifting of waste streams to developing nations than Old Navy or TJ Maxx or Pacific Sun or whichever cheap clothing stores was displaced by fast fashion outlets?
- ggm 5y agoTo the extent that they reduce the cost per item to the floor and encourage people to swap tops to "todays" stripe, yes. The counter argument would be that they do more demand response and so produce less surplus where Tj Maxx and the like have to pre order to estimated demand. So one (Shein) might be less bad per unit style but encourages more rapid churn. The other traditional model claims fast, but is slower, but has higher upfront build and ship consequences.
- bee_rider 5y agoIf I remember correctly, TJ Maxx usually buys excess product from other brands (and possibly removes or covers up branding if requested). So they contribute less to this problem -- if anything they give less successful runs a second chance should mitigate damage slightly I guess. I don't think this detracts from your broader point, though -- your specific example just happened to be the unusual exception to an otherwise good rule.
- addicted 5y agoOld Navy is also fast fashion. TJ Maxx is interesting in that it is fast fashion but it provides a useful outlet for clothes that would otherwise have been trashed. So immediately it is a positive since it ensures more clothes are worn than they would have been otherwise. In the long run, however, by providing those clothes value beyond their original life TJ Maxx helps prop up the finances of fast fashion, so maybe it’s a net negative? It’s not clear to me.
- usrusr 5y agoEven if everything else was exactly the same, they'd still make it considerably worse by removing trying out the fit from the equation. There's no way of running a try/return/send to next buyer cycle on that price level, it's all about best guess and eating the cost. Reminds me if how the IP family of protocols, unlike protocols from the old telephony tradition, does not promise anything about the connection before the packet is sent out. Only that this time there's actual stuff ending up in bins. At retail fast fashion, fitting booths have not yet entirely disappeared.
- sydthrowaway 5y agoWhats the alternative ?
- ggm 5y agoA higher degree of oversight by government than we want these days and less individual variability without personal effort: more handmade sewed goods. Frankly there isn't much alternative.
- night862 5y agoOn the charitable and ecological end of the spectrum, there is of course thrift/flea/second-hand shops, church or garage sales. Availability varies quite a bit especially seasonally or following economic trends. It definitely takes a lot more effort. A bit farther along you can find arbitrage type businesses reselling lots or whole sale and warehouse overstock, army/navy/surplus, vintage boutiques upselling estates or whatever wont sell in retail stores for whatever reason. This is an easy option, but the price is higher since someone is curating a selection or otherwise squeezing a profit from what might've been refuse. A lot of the old-school sources (flea, thrift) have been experiencing additional inventory pressure caused by another great option which is depop, etsy, ebay, or other online shops (even goodwill has an online auction site[0]). Tons of practical, uncommon, and cool thrift finds are available online at the general cost of people farming thrift and flea markets for popular sizes, driving up prices and reducing popular sized stocks. But this also keeps tons of old weird stuff in peoples closets out of the garbage by granting a more obvious value proposition. GenZ people seem to be embracing this quite a bit. It sounds like a fun side-hustle for a college student. Frankly, if you are buying regular wardrobe, I'd make the fairly obvious recommendation of just simply buying practical, usable, and good quality. If what you buy works well and lasts a reasonable period, thats a great definition of value to follow towards the best manufacturers. Maybe buy it from a store you like and don't worry about it if we've stopped the urge to buy a little bit of trash because we feel weird at 2am. We is me. Most of the fast fashion cheap stuff is uselessly flimsy, but maybe it would work alright for a costume or some kind of bedroom scenario. I guess in one respect fast fashion is useful insofar as its hard to find some of that weird one-off junk-stuff in a thrift store or even the mall, because nobody will buy it. Its ugly and the fabric is itchy. [0] https://shopgoodwill.com/ https://shopgoodwill.com/
- 4oh9do 5y ago> Fast fashion is a root cause of a huge amount of fabric waste, plastic waste, and cost shifting of waste streams to developing nations. How does all of that waste compare to all of the waste involved in making your comment? Not just the infra required to host it and distribute it, but the devices required for you to make it. Kind of turning a blind eye to the amount of "cost shifting of waste streams to developing nations" that electronic devices create.
- foepys 5y agoThis is whataboutism. Fast fashion clothing often falls apart after a single wash and at the latest after two. They are meant to worn once and then to be disposed. I agree that some electronics like smartphones should be made to last for more than 2 years but fast fashion creates much, much more plastic waste on its own. We already know how to make longer lasting, more environment friendly clothing, so it's not like we couldn't do any better.
- Semaphor 5y ago> Fast fashion clothing often falls apart after a single wash and at the latest after two Is that hyperbole? Or is it really that bad? I always thought fast fashion meant stuff like those cheap Amazon brands (!Solid etc.) that only last around a year…
- bobthepanda 5y agoYour mileage may vary. Anecdotally, it seems like women’s fast fashion falls apart a lot faster than men’s apparel from the same brands. And some brands are a lot worse than others (e.g. Forever 21 is a lot worse than H&M)
- Semaphor 5y agoWorse than H&M? Wow.
- 5y ago
- ThomPete 5y agoeverything have external cost just like it has external benefits. The question is whether they ad up or whether its outsized in one direction.
- DoingIsLearning 5y ago> Fast fashion is a root cause of a huge amount of fabric waste, plastic waste, and cost shifting of waste streams to developing nations. And water waste. [0] Most people have no idea how water intensive the textile dyeing of their clothes really is. Buy high quality clothes and wear them as long as possible. [0] https://www.unep.org/news-and-stories/story/putting-brakes-fast-fashion https://www.unep.org/news-and-stories/story/putting-brakes-f...
- machiaweliczny 5y agoI love my adidas hoodie that already is 10y+ The sad truth is that quality clothig is not available in many countries. All my best stuff was bought in France. In Poland they sell crap(too small after washing 3 times, super thin) and even more expensive. There are some local companies with quality stuff but they are niche.
- teekert 5y agoAbsolutely, I've been on a quest to find fair trade and responsible clothing since I watched this show (sorry in Dutch): [0]. It's pretty clearly aimed at fashionable youth which I'm not but I still found it utterly confronting. The conditions that the workers live in (I say live but it's often just sleep and the rest is work) are crazy. They are sleeping above formalin baths. swimming in chemicals that slowly cause burn wounds, they live near rivers that are bright blue from dyes. Cotton fields take all water in an area away from humans who need it more. Luckily there are alternatives, in the Netherlands I found [1] (apologies, also in Dutch), and there are many more of such companies. The crazy thing is that it's really not that expensive and they even make the clothing high quality so I have to shop less (I hate shopping). (Ok, so I never really was the target for fast fashion.) I'm open to other suggestions for responsible (quality) clothing. [0]: https://www.npo3.nl/genaaid/VPWON_1295027 https://www.npo3.nl/genaaid/VPWON_1295027 [1]: https://skotfashion.com/nl/our-story/ https://skotfashion.com/nl/our-story/
- najra 5y agoThat's awesome! I'm working for https://fairbee.com https://fairbee.com , a Dutch startup that's trying to get more attention to these kinds of brands, there's a bunch of (Dutch and international) companies trying to do better :) Thanks for the NPO tip: definitely going to watch it :)
- teekert 5y agoGreat, I'll definitely have a look next time I need something. Is there also some kind of label for these ethical clothes? I'm ok with trusting small shops and I understand it might cost them money (perhaps better spend otherwise) to get a label and labels aren't everything, but still... Edit: Are there also brands specifically aiming at quality? So that denim pants just last a lot longer for example? Paying more feels even better if I'm really buying quality. The Skot polo I bought seems to be really good fabric and well made, they also touted that, that really adds a lot to the whole value proposition, for me. Another edit: This is also a nice initiative which could perhaps be leveraged more, specifically by ethical companies: [0] [0]: https://returns.homerr.com/ https://returns.homerr.com/
- okeuro49 5y agoI've noticed that fast fashion is also a gendered problem. I'm often assured that "toxic masculinity" doesn't mean an inherent criticism of masculinity, and is a phrase that many institutions seem to think is a productive way to talk about problems they perceive as being male gendered. I find it interesting to consider whether it would also be productive to refer to fast fashion as "toxic femininity", as it's often literally so, given pesticides, plastics, fertilisers. I will not perhaps be the first to do this, however.
- viraptor 5y agoIs that term giving us better description than concentrating on the fashion part though? Toxic masculinity works because it's about bad traits we as a society teach and normalise for men. I don't think that idea matches this case. The fashion industry is responsible for lots of toxic behaviours both in literally toxic production and in harmful trends for all genders. (Even if women are disproportionately affected)
- wccrawford 5y agoIn that we encourage women to wear clothes in ways that we don't encourage men, yes, I think it is "toxic femininity". Toxic to both women and the planet. We teach them that they can't wear white after a certain time the year, and then black after a certain time. Why? Just because. We teach them never to wear the same outfit as their friend at the same party. We teach that they always have to wear perfect clothes. There are examples of people fighting these things (such as ripped jeans) but they're the rebels, not the norm. So yeah, I think that in regards to most clothing issues, "toxic femininity" definitely applies. For fast fashion... I don't know. I have never paid attention to that scene, so I don't know how much it affects men. Also, I should note that "toxic masculinity" generally only refers to behaviors that straight men show, and not gay men. And is often badly applied.
- micromacrofoot 5y agoone could argue that women’s fashion originated primarily to please men in a patriarchal society
- schnitzelstoat 5y agoI think fast fashion is a behaviour of the individual consumer rather than an attribute of a particular brand though. I suspect wherever you buy the clothes from they likely come from the same sweatshops and factories in Asia just with different markup. Many people say Zara is fast fashion, yet I sit in the Zara clothes that have lasted me 2-3 years. We are fortunate to be able to produce high quality clothing incredibly cheaply due to the wonders of modern manufacturing and the brutal exploitation of foreign labour - yet that won't stop people throwing it in the bin to get the next shiny thing an 'influencer' has shilled.
- joostdecock 5y agoIf you want to avoid fast fashion altogether, you can always roll your own. (Make your own clothes that is). Sure, it's perhaps a bit niche. But there's a thriving open source community at https://FreeSewing.org/ https://FreeSewing.org/ Full disclosure: I am the FreeSewing maintainer
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]