3 ms·
Right. I'm thinking specifically of cases in which, say, a water-control system might utilise such elements, and just how complex they might get. This isn't m
by dredmorbius 5y ago
Right. I'm thinking specifically of cases in which, say, a water-control system might utilise such elements, and just how complex they might get. This isn't my area, so I'm being conservative in statements.
An electronic switch translates to a hydraulic valve.
And a hydraulic valve is a direct analogue of a vacuum tube or transistor: an applied input delivers a controlled input. Often but not necessarily amplified --- there are cases where the input effort might be much larger than the output, in control or precision implementations.
Mind: a valve itself might be water activated, in the sense of a small flow through one channel translating to a large flow in a controlled channel. One obvious example of this is the fantail of a post windmill, where any orientation of the mill's main sails outside the primary wind flow starts spinning the fantail which reorients the mill into the wind. See:
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/6/65/Beebe_Windmill_Isometric_of_Machinery_Long_Island_NY.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/6/65/Beebe_Wi...
There are numerous cases of interlocks, many of which are mechanical. Some of these are through inherently fail-safe designs. A canal's locks, aeroplane doors, and airlocks all open such that they require pressure equalisation, preventing opening whilst the lock and channel are at different levels, or pressurised and depressurised regions are not at equilibrium. Shift-lever and starter interlocks require that brakes be engaged and vehicles in neutral to start, or shift from reverse.
https://realpars.com/interlock/ https://realpars.com/interlock/
And I'm finding a few references specifically to mechanical control logic:
"Mechanical Logic Devices and Circuits"
http://www.nacomm09.ammindia.org/NaCoMM-2009/nacomm09_final_pap/R/RCA18.pdf http://www.nacomm09.ammindia.org/NaCoMM-2009/nacomm09_final_... (PDF)
"PDF Pneumatic Logic & Controls - Parker Hannifin"
https://www.parker.com/literature/Literature%20Files/pneumatic/Literature/Telepneumatic/PCC-4.pdf https://www.parker.com/literature/Literature%20Files/pneumat... (PDF)
The second is a catalogue of available products based on pneumatic logic.
One specific domain in which analogue / mechanical controls have been specifically discussed is for future Venus lander missions. Temperature and pressure profiles are too high for virtually all electronic systems (circuit boards, solder, and componentry would thermally degrade or melt).
JPL have specifically explored the concept of a "clockwork rover", AREE (advanced rover for extreme environments) for a Venus or similar mission:
https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/news/a-clockwork-rover-for-venus https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/news/a-clockwork-rover-for-venus
- credit_guy 5y agoAlso, all the domain of fluidics, such as https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paper-based_microfluidics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paper-based_microfluidics
- dredmorbius 5y agoBeautiful, thanks!