4 ms·
Trolls be gone – The right to be anonymous should be curtailed
- rektide 5y agoRather than rescind voice, i think we need to try some moderation & metamoderation. There's huge problems but we have tried so so so little. We should be building more advanced feedback & critiques of identities, anonymous, psuedononymous, & eponymous (?). We should be looking at recaps & summaries g aggregates of user histories over time when we run into each other. What isnt tolerable is every comment having the same weight. Having throwaways appear at the same merit & virtue as a longstanding user of good regard. We havent even begun to generate the most basic, prelimimary of social defenses. Tonpropose that we should simply start blowing up online speech without having tried doing anything to enlighten & inform ourselves- I find these cries pathetic. Just morally ruinous cowardly & panic stricken folks spewing these warhawk fearmongering cries, beating the wardrums. We have to try empowering each other, try dealing with each other some, before we start resorting to convenient banning of speech. In my view there have been next to no initiatives to promote & extend a social democracy. We've let trolls have the power by making all voices look the same, by letting information & speakers not be subject to social review & criticism & defense: that is the enemy here, the free pass, the lack of social defense.
- ssss11 5y agoEvery time “we must stop x because of small group y” comes up I wonder if there is some other ulterior motive. Why would we punish the masses for the poor behaviour of a small subset. Figure out ways to punish the subset and let everyone else be.
- ggm 5y agoIt's unlikely any call for a removal of anonymity will be well supported by the digital cognoscenti. There's too much strong reinforcing belief it's bad. It's definitional for a specific subset of users that to use their true names exposes them to abuse. LGBTQI experience this as do a significant number of women. Not that women and the six letter community don't troll, they do. Just, there's an inevitability of receiving completely unrelated, misogynistic and sexualising violent responses to posts, if you are visible enough and in these communities. What I think fails to be appreciated is that getting rid of anonymity is not in itself sufficient: it also demands higher penalty for breach of posting rules. Personally I support ends to anonymity on most public channels and highly constrained pseudonymity in most channels. And I say this as one who has been shadowbanned for breach of regs. A very fine blogger journalist called George Megalogenis says this on his blog comment pages: "my blog my rules" and he removes what he considers taint, with ascerbic comments. I see this as an exemplar of good editorial practice. A comment I've seen made is that non anonymous bullies continue to plague women: for some reason a significant minority of identifyable trolls will actually say outrageously nasty things to a women with the nerve to speak out in public. I know that this comment too will attract a "not all men" or "sticks and stones" response, but I still believe this is true: ending anonymity may help but won't actually bury the patriarchy. (Examples in Australian politics esp. Twitter abound) A lot of stuff on HN goes dark quickly. Brigading, pile ons. Outside in the semi public sphere it's worse, and happens faster.
- wmf 5y agoAgreed. Many people assume that identified users will automatically be held accountable for their trolling but history shows that this isn't happening. If we want better behavior we need to demand accountability directly. Anonymity is a side issue.
- jfengel 5y agoI support ends to anonymity on most public channels and highly constrained pseudonymity in most channels I concur with that. The key constraint that I don't see much is some measure of pseudonymity reputation. It's very easy in most channels to create a new account and continue harassment. So even if you have the tools to say "I don't want to hear from this person", those tools are easily subverted. I can think of a lot of metrics for confidence that an account has some merit. Age is an easy one: HN marks new accounts, and I think more sites should do that. You can create more complicated trust metrics. If you add that, an anonymous account is one with zero trust. Add in a tool that says "I only want to hear from people with X% trustworthiness". It's not a silver bullet. It certainly doesn't stop people from talking about you, which is a harder problem. The only answers I have there would be to enforce libel rules, which is easier if you force accounts to be identified in some way, but the American standard of proving libel is very high. I'd also really like to see law enforcement take online threats seriously, but they don't. People will make threats on accounts under their own names, and the law will generally assume that they won't act -- which is true, but that doesn't make it legal. And that encourages people to use it as a tactic to shut others up, because "grow a thicker skin" is harder in the face of violence.
- fontenot-jon 5y agothis nation was founded by refugees of tyranny using anonymous communications... nuff said.