3 ms·
I'm going to disagree with the sibling responses here and agree with your premise - I actually think in some cases it's not fair to calculate APR for short term
by nlh 5y ago
I'm going to disagree with the sibling responses here and agree with your premise - I actually think in some cases it's not fair to calculate APR for short term, low value loans. Here's why: There's a transaction cost with making a loan - paperwork, time, etc., and in many cases that transaction cost doesn't scale with the loan size.
Example to illustrate: Let's say I ask you for a personal loan. If I need $100,000 and I want to pay you back over a few years, let's say you charge me 5% APR. You write me a check and you can roughly count on the fact that I'm going to pay you ~$5,000 a year for the service. I get the money I need, you make a nice return, we're both happy.
Now let's say I need $100 for a week. If you charged me the same 5% APR, that means I pay you back about $100.096 next week. Is it worth it? Pretty good deal for me - I'm happy to get a week's usage of $100 and it only cost me a dime. Pretty bad deal for you - and in fact, I expect you wouldn't want to even do the deal. Not worth the risk!
So what do you charge me? What's it worth to hand me a $100 and hope you'll get it back in a week? $1? Still pretty low - and that's 52% APR! $5? Getting closer - now you can buy a beer or two at the bar next week. But that's 260%! $10? Now we're at 520% APR.
It doesn't really scale at low numbers.
- wbc 5y agothese amounts (10, 50, 100, w/e) are being lent on a minute by minute basis and are paid back in a week: https://www.kucoin.com/margin/lend/USDT https://www.kucoin.com/margin/lend/USDT USD transaction cost might be too high if the technology doesn't exist
- simplestats 5y agoI agree that one single metric like APR is not sufficient to compare all possible cases of lending without making some options to look worse than they really are. But if you were a safe enough borrower to even get a $100k loan, then you're sfe to loan $100 to for a tiny return also. Payday loans probably tend to be for people who can't get better loans of any size.