3 ms·
> As you say, some will benefit from autonomy more than others... I think that actually sugar-coats a truly cruel approach. It's not "some benefit more than ot
by shadowgovt 5y ago
> As you say, some will benefit from autonomy more than others...
I think that actually sugar-coats a truly cruel approach. It's not "some benefit more than others," it's "some benefit while others suffer."
Pushing the autonomy slider to its limit is just breaking governance and letting the strong rule. Maximum freedom is nature red in tooth and claw. We build heteronomous structures to escape that chaos.
Of course, pushing the slider all the way towards heteronomy is also terrible. But given these two thought experiments, I fail to see how one passes moral judgement on someone who likes the slider tweaked a bit further towards either extreme than I do... "Moral judgment," to my mind, implies an absolute virtue that is absent from the equation. It's a struggle for balance, not for supremacy.