3 ms·
This rule would functionally kill small Internet service provision and build the biggest moat around the incumbent providers that has ever been handed to them.
by shadowgovt 5y ago
This rule would functionally kill small Internet service provision and build the biggest moat around the incumbent providers that has ever been handed to them.
... which may, indeed, be the right solution.
- mysecretaccount 5y agoAs long as ${some number} is large enough it will not impact "small ISP" at all.
- shadowgovt 5y agoThat's the thing about being an Internet startup... You never know when you're going to explode and suddenly jump from a ten-thousand-user service to a milliion-user service. So supporting this would require a company to take all manner of new precautions that companies currently don't (circuit-breaker on the new account creation system? But then your growth stalls and your potential customers go to a competitor instead, and you don't blow up into a YouTube or a Twitter like YouTube and Twitter did).
- pdpi 5y agoOr the simpler solution: Once your revenue goes over the threshold, you have a period of 6/12 months to go into compliance, or something similar.
- selfhoster11 5y agoIf you're suddenly a million-user service, you should easily have enough revenue to implement the regulations during a grace period.
- shadowgovt 5y agoAssuming you have a revenue model. What was Twitter's revenue model when they had their first million users?
- TheSpiceIsLife 5y agoGrace period - A grace period is a period immediately after the deadline for an obligation during which a late fee, or other action that would have been taken as a result of failing to meet the deadline, is waived provided that the obligation is satisfied during the grace period. In other words, it is a length of time during which rules or penalties are waived or deferred. Grace periods can range from a number of minutes to a number of days or longer, and can apply in situations including arrival at a job, paying a bill, or meeting a government or legal requirement. In law, a grace period is a time period during which a particular rule exceptionally does not apply, or only partially applies. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grace_period https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grace_period
- samhw 5y agoDo you mean because those 'small Internet service providers' would be included in his 'larger than $MARKET_SHARE' group, or because it would mean no one was kicked out of the incumbent services and therefore there would be fewer new customers available?
- shadowgovt 5y agoI mean because a company tends to explode from "smaller than $MARKET_SHARE" to "larger than $MARKET_SHARE" in a discontinuous fashion. So since a company can't really predict when it will happen, every company providing service would need to prep from the ground up to provide the described level of relatively non-automated high-touch support this proposal describes. It'd raise the cost to build a startup. ... not to imply it's a bad idea; there's no golden rule that says an ecosystem of millions of competing companies is always a superior alternative to a few well-regulated players. It's just important to note the hidden costs.
- matsemann 5y agoSame argument used against gdpr all the time, and proven false all the time. It's easy to be small and compliant.
- shadowgovt 5y agoYou can comply with GDPR by refraining from collecting data. You can't provide an online service while refraining from providing an online service.
- bee_rider 5y agoI think this limitation is an artifact of the fact that the proposal is an idea being tossed out on social media. A real law would have some sort of grace period. That grace period could be chosen arbitrarily, it should be set such that any well-run company would have time to respond.
- OkayPhysicist 5y agoIf you have automated rule enforcement, then you already have a formal specification of your rules, and informing the user of what rule they have broken should be trivial. If you have humans doing the bans manually, then you already have a human in the loop.