8 ms·
Practice test: https://mathproficiencytest.ca/#/en/sample-questions-pre https://mathproficiencytest.ca/#/en/sample-questions-pre
by pseudolus 5y ago
Practice test: https://mathproficiencytest.ca/#/en/sample-questions-pre https://mathproficiencytest.ca/#/en/sample-questions-pre
- 542458 5y agoIt’s worth noting that this practice test was not available at the time the requirement was put in place (P18 of the judgement). While teachers that were raised in Ontario would be somewhat familiar with the grades 1-9 math curriculum, teachers not from the region would be more or less going in blind in terms of what content to expect. This is one factor that affected the judgement.
- sanxiyn 5y agoThat's bad (tests definitely should publish practice tests), but for god's sake, it's grade math curriculum. It should be passable without any practice.
- koolba 5y agoHaving taken a look at those sample questions, would you really want a teacher who cannot complete them without explicitly preparing for them to be teaching your children? They're not particularly complicated and I'd expect not only every teacher to able to complete them, but every student as well. This continuous dumbing down standards in the interests of equality of outcome does not end well for anybody.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThe only thing that makes sense about lowering standards rather than increasing efforts to help people meet those standards is this is a consequence of increasing labor prices, and an attempt to keep expenses lower by not having to compete for well qualified teaching candidates. End result will be further stratification of society via price segmentation where well resourced members of society can afford to purchase better quality education. This already happens, but these measures will help it become even more stratified across more of the population.
- 542458 5y agoHonestly, I’m fine with my kid’s dance or history or whatever teacher not being able to pass that seeing as how the test was given blind and in a high-pressure environment. The judgement seems pretty clear that the province was not able to demonstrate that teacher math scores produce significantly better student scores - any correlation was weak at best. It appears that pedagogy skills are far more important than being able to ace a standardized test. If there had been a demonstration otherwise my option would be different. To be clear, teachers who teach subject X should know enough to teach it (once given sufficient prep time), but I don’t care if they know subject Y, or if they lock up when given a standardized test. Maybe I’m just a bit more sympathetic than normal here since I always did poorly on big high-pressure math tests (but could do non-test-based content with flying colors).
- dahfizz 5y agoAs mentioned elsewhere in this thread, teachers in Ontario (and most places, I imagine) do not specialize in a subject until high school or so. So most teachers needs to be able to teach every subject. This is besides the point though, in my opinion. Any teacher being unable to do basic arithmetic is extremely alarming. It calls into question their entire credentials as a teacher. Anyone who graduated high school, let alone college should be able to do arithmetic. This isn't a case of teacher in subject X has some knowledge gaps about subject Y. This is a case of a teacher missing basic adult competencies.
- ceautery 5y agoAfter looking at a handful of questions, I'd want a teacher who couldn't initially pass this test to be trained in math at this level first, but not disqualified from teaching. Teach them what they need that they're missing.
- merpnderp 5y agoIf they can’t do basic grade school math, it’s probably safe to assume their entire education is extremely limited and they’re functionally illiterate. Like can’t balance their check book illiterate. So I wouldn’t expect them to have the rounded peripheral knowledge needed for a top tier education. Why would we want people with such poor educations teaching children?
- ceautery 5y agoYou're confusing literacy with numeracy. To give you a counter-example to what you're saying, my son reads above grade level, but has math anxiety, and would struggle with some of the questions that mixed percents and fractions, especially on a timed test. If he decides he wants to teach, he'll be great at it, but he'll need to level up in math skill and get more comfortable with juggling numbers in his head. Your comment about wanting better-educated people to teach is legit. But we have, in America at least, run-down areas with crappy primary schools. Some of those kids will feel a calling to teach. What should we do about that? Find resources to help them get to where they need to be, or tell them they're too dumb?
- merpnderp 5y agoIf they've finished college and plan on going into education and can't mix fractions and percents, then it has nothing to do with their primary school math scores. Which is actually a much larger question - how are teachers graduating from university without being able to do 5th grade math?
- candiodari 5y agohttps://www.oise.utoronto.ca/mt/UserFiles/File/Master_of_Teaching_Courses_website.pdf https://www.oise.utoronto.ca/mt/UserFiles/File/Master_of_Tea... So to become a teacher you have to complete either 36 or 72 hours of math education over a single 6 month period, even teaching math in grade 12. That's it. That's less than 2 hours of math per week over 6 months. More scary is that it DOESN'T mention exams. There seems to be no need to actually remember anything. You have to complete "practicum" which seems to be 2 months of helping out a teacher in a classroom, and "more" in the second year.
- NikolaeVarius 5y agoAny adult should be able to go in blind and ace this test. Why do people set the bar so low
- NDizzle 5y agoWhy are these low bars being lowered even further, every single passing year? That should be the next question one asks themselves...
- ceautery 5y agoI would love to live in that world.
- candiodari 5y agoWait till you see the test that is asked of Police officers. There's a joke about that one goes something like this: The only question is "how much is 2+2 ?". Any answer between -3 and 22 except 4 is considered correct.
- whitexn--g28h 5y agoThere is a huge advantage in a lot of the questions in knowing shortcuts and simplifying the questions. Someone with a strong math background is going to find this a lot easier better than someone who struggles with math.
- creato 5y agoSounds like the test measures proficiency in math then. A math proficiency test if you will.
- whitexn--g28h 5y agoMaybe a math competency test is more appropriate.
- Rygian 5y agoFor a test called "Math proficiency test" that sounds about right.
- jetsetgo 5y ago
- clavicat 5y ago"People who are good at math will be good at this math test."
- soperj 5y agoWhat grade is this supposed to be for?
- sanxiyn 5y agoThis is for teachers. Unbelievable, I know.
- neom 5y agoI have dyscalculia to the nth, I couldn't complete this test, I closed it after the first question. Although I wouldn't want to teach math, I'm perfectly well qualified to teach art.
- prvc 5y agoHow would you teach perspective?
- neom 5y agoIs geometry considered pure math? Funny you should ask, I was I thinking about that, I guess I'd just teach it via leading lines, and maybe look at the required geography prior to the class. Although I have a degree in art and I've never considered perspective in the context of geometric math, and I'm not sure it would be required to teach primary school art (or high school for that matter?)
- prvc 5y agoGeometry is indeed math, and understanding perspective is impossible without it.
- Minor49er 5y ago> dyscalculia to the nth I see what you did there
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jasode 5y agoThanks for the link. I went through the 5 intro sample questions and clicked on all 45 questions in the next section. It looks like basic math grade-school curriculum such as fractions, percentages, arithmetic, etc. I didn't see any high-school subjects like trigonometry, or algebra like completing the square to solve a quadratic equation, or adding matrices. It's definitely not like the challenging college tests (SAT/GMAT/GRE). The first 5 questions I saw were: What is the value of 7.05+5+1.5+2.05+4.57.05+5+1.5+2.05+4.5 ? What is 17.86÷0.19 ? What is the sum of the following set of four numbers? 0.02, 0.6, 0.735, 0.00050.02, 0.6, 0.735, 0.0005 What number is represented by this expanded form? (3×1000000)+(2×10000)+(7×1000)+(9×100)+(6×10)+(8×1) What is 6905÷34 ?
- josephcsible 5y agoAlso, since these are multiple choice, they're all really easy to solve in ways that they wouldn't be if you had to fill in a blank.
- f00zz 5y agoYeah, I think they're testing if someone will recognize that division by 0.19 is approximately equal to multiplication by 5 and ballpark the answer.
- gpm 5y agoThe section after that (the pedagogy section) is different though, and was explicitly called out in the ruling as part of the problem: Question 1: "Based on Learning For All, which is a shared goal or strategy of differentiated instruction and Universal Design for Learning? A) To use the same textbooks B) To use only whole-class instruction C) To meet different needs of the students in a class D) To meet the requirements for curriculum expectations" Question 6 (just clicking through randomly): "Assessment that occurs before a period of learning to assess a student's readiness for learning and learning preferences would be considered which of the following? A) assessment of learning B) assessment as learning C) assessment for learning D) assessment of learning skills" Question 15: "As outlined in Growing Success, how does Ontario’s criterion-referenced assessment and evaluation approach require teachers to assess and evaluate students’ work? A) by ranking student performance B) by comparing work done by other students C) by referencing performance standards developed by teachers for their own classrooms D) by referencing the established criteria for four levels of achievement that are standard across the province"
- LegitShady 5y ago...I passed this test without knowing any of the reading materials for section 3 (just by guessing what seemed reasonable). This was a very basic elementary school math test. Section 1 - 5/5 Section 2 - 44/45 Section 3 - 16/21 ~91% If you can't prepare for and pass this test you really shouldn't be teaching anyone anything.
- newjersey 5y ago> Section 1 - 5/5 Section 2 - 44/45 Section 3 - 16/21 Thank you for sharing your score. Mine (practice test 1, English) was Section 1 - 5/5 Section 2 - 43/45 Section 3 - 13/21. These are the questions I got incorrect Section 2: questions 12, 33 (I know I don't have any excuse as a math major in college). Section 3: questions: 4, 7, 8, 9, 11, 17, 19, 21. When I went into this test, I thought this was for students and was trying to figure out which grade students would take this test. There were multiple questions which made me do a double take because I thought "surely this must be a trick question I am missing the point of". > If you can't prepare for and pass this test you really shouldn't be teaching anyone anything. 13/21 is 61% which is failing score. I think section three of the test should be removed.
- threatofrain 5y agoBut this is without any studying or pedagogical training. You did pretty well and so did the commentator above you.
- LegitShady 5y ago>13/21 is 61% which is failing score. I think section three of the test should be removed. You didn't know any of the material, no wonder. But my guess is that section 3 is there to improve pass rates - teachers who can't do basic math but can read and regurgitate slides/notes. It probably pushes a lot of people over the 70% pass. I got 16/21 on that section just guessing what sounded reasonable. If I had read a book or notes on it I'd probably ace it. It's a gimme.
- PascLeRasc 5y agoThe pedagogy section would really bother me as a teacher (https://i.imgur.com/3s9mVY5.png https://i.imgur.com/3s9mVY5.png). They shouldn't be evaluated on the semantics of different mission statements.
- LegitShady 5y agoit sounds like they needed to read a book and learn some concepts from it. That's something you'd expect from any student.
- cpcallen 5y agoThanks for this. I think the test is pretty interesting: - The first and second sections test math skills up to about a grade five or six level, at least based on what I learned in Ontario schools in the 1980s. - The third section seems pretty suggestive of the philosophy of the teacher training system. I didn't have much trouble guessing 16/21 questions correctly, despite never having read any of the referenced books. - I would love to see how scores on the first and second sections of the test correlate with answers to the questionnaire that forms section four. - I'm not sure what the pass standard for this test is, but I would be rather concerned if teachers who had scored less than 75% on the first two sections were permitted to teach mathematics (or science) above a grade 4 level. (Certain choices of answers on the questionnaire section would also provoke similar concerns.)
- Thiez 5y agoLooks like 70% is a pass: https://mathproficiencytest.ca/#/en/applicant/learn/results:partial_success https://mathproficiencytest.ca/#/en/applicant/learn/results:...