4 ms·
> [the system] sends up to several emails that simulate real user inquiries about GDPR or CCPA processes. This research method is analogous to the audit and “s
by h2odragon 5y ago
> [the system] sends up to several emails that simulate real user inquiries about GDPR or CCPA processes. This research method is analogous to the audit and “secret shopper” methods that are common in academic research, enabling realistic evaluation of business practices.
That was the whole problem. An open "we're researching responses" would've been fine. A murky "we're someone who looks fake talking about nebulous legal consequences" Isn't going to be welcomed anywhere, is it?
This is a better response than I expected, and I wish them luck and success in communicating the lessons they've learned here more widely.
- jhgb 5y ago> An open "we're researching responses" would've been fine. That seems to be highly unscientific/prone to skewing the sample. It probably would have rendered the results useless.
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoIf you can't study something ethically, the conclusion is not that you get to ignore the ethical problem, the conclusion is that you can't study it.
- jhgb 5y agoYes, perhaps they should have hired real people to do real requests. That would have been a bulletproof way of studying this ethically so your conclusion is moot.
- dogleash 5y ago>That seems to be highly unscientific/prone to skewing the sample. I'd argue the emails they did send are MORE prone to skewing the sample. If I had no CCPA plan and got an email from someone introducing themselves as researchers, I'd tell them I haven't gotten around to it, and that I intend to comply but haven't had anything prompt me to put in effort regarding CCPA. If I got the email they did send, that would be exactly the request that makes me go do the legal research, and my response would as narrow as possible.