3 ms·
Same here, but I never understood how BSD jails or Solaris zones are better over normal hardware virtualization which is used in Qubes OS. In addition, you get
by fsflover 5y ago
Same here, but I never understood how BSD jails or Solaris zones are better over normal hardware virtualization which is used in Qubes OS. In addition, you get a great UX in the latter.
- nix23 5y ago> Same here, but I never understood how BSD jails or Solaris zones are better over normal hardware virtualization which is used in Qubes OS. In addition, you get a great UX in the latter. Tells me you don't know the difference between HW-Virtualisation and OS-Virtualisation.
- laumars 5y agoContainerisation makes much more sense than virtualisation in a lot of areas: * lower runtime overhead * quicker deployment time * smaller image foot print Plus most of the advantages of VMs can still be applied. However it does massively depend on individual use cases. Qubes aims to be ultra secure and containers in Linux weren’t up to that task at the time (the situation has since improved massively).
- StreamBright 5y ago- lower runtime overhead - quicker deployment time - smaller image foot print Firecracker beg to differ. I think you can do virtualisation and have all three you listed.
- laumars 5y agoSure. But for every edge case where virtualisation bridges the gap, there will be containerisation solutions that further the gap too. Also I’m not really in the mood to engage in a dumb flame war. I’m just answering the question as to why some people favour containers for some workflows. If firecracker works for you then keep at it.
- throwawayboise 5y agoWith modern hardware support for virtualization, is runtime overhead still a big deal (assuming your virtual environments are not emulating some other CPU?)
- laumars 5y agoDepends on the industry. For general purpose computing it’s generally not an issue but it does matter for some specific workflows. I tend to look at it the other way though: given containerisation is so easy these days, what are the compelling reasons to run virtual machines. Neither is a wrong answer though.
- throwawayboise 5y agoVMs still provide better isolation and security, or is that no longer true?
- laumars 5y agoThey do but not by a significant margin these days. The kind of domains where this is an issue isn’t what you’re average engineer would be concerned with. Where VMs do help the average engineer is they have more secure defaults. It’s pretty easy to accidentally run containers insecurely on Linux (FreeBSD jails are a better story though)
- gaadd33 5y agoI don't think Qubes OS existed around 2000, did it?
- fsflover 5y agoI was asking about what to use now.
- nix23 5y agoFor what? That would be the first thing to know.....
- fsflover 5y agoFor security and workflow separation. What else is there?
- nix23 5y agoOn your phone, a desktop a server? For real-time applications, HPC, analytics, ML/AI? Hardware virtualization has tradeoffs...sometimes massive ones, and then you trust proprietary hardware to make it faster...again.
- fsflover 5y agoAre you using open hardware for software virtualization? I'm curious which. > On your phone, a desktop a server? Phone doesn't support hardware virtualization of course. On my laptop I'm using Qubes OS.
- nix23 5y ago>Phone doesn't support hardware virtualization of course. Every CPU "supports" hardware virtualization. >software virtualization? That's a "VM" like JVM, we talk about OS-Virtualisation.
- freemint 5y agoAlso OS level emulation. Linux system calls can be translated to Solaris system calls allowing to run Linux specific workloads without having to emulate hardware and a full Linux kernels. Furthermore before Dtrace was ported Linux it allowed to debug Linux workloads under DTrace.
- trasz 5y agoYou can do both with FreeBSD in the exact same way.
- freemint 5y agoI am fully aware. Parent was probably not.
- NexRebular 5y agoUnless the software is "vendor locked" with linuxisms. I wish I could run everything only on zones but alas, still have to mix in some bhyves as well for e.g. docker support...