3 ms·
Running a multi-tenant datacenter or hyper scale cloud datacenter is a different business than running a datacenter. The myth of the cost of running facilities
by Spooky23 5y ago
Running a multi-tenant datacenter or hyper scale cloud datacenter is a different business than running a datacenter. The myth of the cost of running facilities on HN is insane - it’s like saying you can’t drive a car unless you hire a formula 1 driver.
I worked through the ranks at a large enterprise that ran a “big” datacenter for a decade. The facilities team was about 6 people, average salary around $90k. I can only remember one power interruption affecting more than a rack, caused by a failure during a maintenance event that requires a shutdown for safety reasons. The rest is like any other industrial facility - you have service contracts for the equipment, etc and maintain things.
There’s a cost/capability curve that you need to plan around for these matters. You need to make business and engineering decisions based on your actual circumstances. If the answer is automatically “AWS <whatever>“, you’re making a decision to burn dollars for convenience.
- mbesto 5y ago> The facilities team was about 6 people, average salary around $90k. Ok so $540k salaries + benefits, so ~$700k. Then you have transaction costs: - Annual salary increases - Any cost associated with people leaving (severance, hiring, recruiters, HR, HR systems) - Systems that run in the data center (logging, monitoring, etc.) - Procurement costs with changing costs in hardware (silicon shortages, etc.) - Security compliance overhead and associated risks - Finance resources required to capitalize and manage asset allocation - etc. etc. Versus - Click a button and voila it works. - Hire way less engineers to manage the system administrative portion > If the answer is automatically “AWS <whatever>“, you’re making a decision to burn dollars for convenience. 100% AGREE. The answer is always "it depends", but just like people are saying "just put in the cloud", the opposite of "well it worked for us using a data center" isn't that simple.
- Spooky23 5y agoSay all of those costs are $2,000,000, and you have 25,000 billable endpoints in the datacenter… you’re looking at less than $0.01/hour for that overhead on a unit basis. Obviously, there’s a huge capital investment component too that has to be incorporated. Those costs may be really high if you’re in a growth phase as you need to overbuy capacity. Just to be clear, I’m not arguing that on-prem is magically cheap. :) But it has its place too!
- mbesto 5y agoAgreed on all accounts.
- f6v 5y agoThat’s not what parent was asking about. The question is if a company of certain size is more likely to suffer from an outage on AWS compared to own hardware. I’ve been deploying to AWS for years and can’t remember and outage on their side in my region. But this is anecdotal and doesn’t necessarily reflect the statistics.