5 ms·
mac left the ship once they refused to embrace standards like Vulkan and let OpenGL rot at the same time.
by ekianjo 5y ago
mac left the ship once they refused to embrace standards like Vulkan and let OpenGL rot at the same time.
- indymike 5y agoI wonder how much gaming reduces consumption of music and long-form video.
- taneq 5y agoCan't speak for everyone but I sure struggle to engage as much with long-form non-interactive media these days. If I'm not affecting a narrative in some meaningful way it's really hard to stay interested.
- tra3 5y agoWhat do you like in terms of "interactive media"? Are you talking strictly games or something? When you said "interactive media", my mind immediately went to tell tale games, "Wolf Among Us" [0]. It's more of an animated story with limited interactivity, but I really enjoyed it. Would love more of this kinda low key gaming. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Wolf_Among_Us https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Wolf_Among_Us
- taneq 5y agoHmm. It set in back when I was playing WoW and realised that the effort I was putting into gaming the auction house was exactly the same as the effort I'd need to make money flipping items on eBay or something. After a while I couldn't make myself care about the in-game goals because I could just be using the same effort IRL for far more significant reward. Then a few years later I spent a bunch of time playing Factorio, to similar effect. Downside: Suddenly flipped from "wow this is awesome" to "man this game feels like a job, it's no longer fun" to "uh, my job is basically this game so... yay?" Now between the two it's really hard to get excited about something that isn't managing a real life business and building useful IP. Am I old? :P
- tra3 5y agoYeah, I could never get into those games 'cause they felt too much like work. Instead of factorio I'd rather write some fun code. Instead of WoW, I'd rather go exploring the woods. But you do need recreation. Games could be fun again, depending on the level of effort, etc
- fiedzia 5y agoGames include music, so the answer for that part is "not at all". Many games offer music at additional cost, so there is a market for that. Also certainly some games made their music iconic in the same way movies used to do it.
- dijit 5y agoIt's not really an accident, Apple strongly dislikes AAA games (note: not AA games like fortnite or .. "games" like candy crush). If they support any kind of game development it's purely indie or puzzle style in nature and not high fidelity. The reasons are.. well incalculable, there are so many: To be competitive you must work closely with driver manufacturers; you would likely need to segment your desktop class hardware platforms based on what games they can play, you might bef forced to update hardware on a significantly shorter cadence- probably support for third party upgrades (like graphics cards). Also, Apple strongly dislikes nvidia who have a stranglehold on AAA games. (ever since they sold them a bunch of cards that desoldered themselves) Apple wants to be a computing platform, and for "creatives". That's the image they're going for. They can't win on gaming, even if they wanted to, but it's against the brand image to go for that market anyway. You can't really do AAA gaming on a mac, and that's ok, not everything has to be about playing games.
- kevingadd 5y agoApple loves AAA games if they're on the iOS store and bringing in billions USD per year of microtransaction revenue from teens and compulsive gamblers. They can't get that by supporting native APIs for non-App-Store desktop games.
- dijit 5y agoWhile I was mainly talking about MacOS (the desktop); Does iOS support AAA games? I haven't been promoted any AAA games on iOS- fortnite is not a AAA game. Edit: argue your point phantom downvoters. Fortnite is not AAA; God Of War, Horizon Zero Dawn, Tom Clancy's the Division are AAA. Find a source that calls fortnite AAA. Find any source of a AAA studio working collaboratively with Apple and I will retract everything I said.
- mastax 5y agoCan you define AAA in a way that excludes Fortnite, and "AAA studio" in a way that excludes Epic Games?
- pjmlp 5y agoMost AAA studios don't care about such standards, as proven by game consoles and Metal already being supported by Unreal, Unity, Ogre3D, Xenko/Stride, among others.
- tpush 5y agoDifferent graphics APIs aren't a reason not to develop for a platform. Game consoles have unique APIs, yet both AAAs and Indies happily develop for those platforms. What matters is whether the prospective income from those platforms outweigh the additional dev costs. Additionally, most Macs simply aren't gaming machines; they're mostly thin laptops or AIOs with very high resolution screens, meaning the GPU has less cooling headroom and has way more pixels to draw than pretty much all Windows machines that are used for gaming. That makes the potential pool of users even smaller than it already is, so most of the time it doesn't make sense to develop games for the Mac.
- vimy 5y agoApple silicon changes this. Macs have plenty of gpu power now for AAA games.
- sliken 5y agoIndeed, and what will keep being even more true as apple silicon evolves and the PS5 and XSX stay the same for 5 years or so. Likely related to this, I've heard that both Sony and Microsoft have approached apple about getting more games on their platform.
- imbnwa 5y agoAnd a much better temperature story
- jonny_eh 5y ago> Different graphics APIs aren't a reason not to develop for a platform. > What matters is whether the prospective income from those platforms outweigh the additional dev costs. Different APIs increase costs. If dev costs were lower for porting games, the platform would see more games.
- tpush 5y ago1) Porting costs are not per game but per engine, which can be shared between multiple games. 2) The majority of costs is ongoing support, not writing to a different API.
- MayeulC 5y agoNot only that, but it has a lot of pain points, including ARM CPUs in a world where a lot of games used to target 32 bit windows. Proton supported macos at first[1]. I think support is still more or less there, though not integrated with "steam play". Proton "glue" scripts are also mostly python, and macos does not (did not?) support python3. I think the community could step in and help support it, but valve pretty much stopped efforts on that front (some rationale in [2]), although I think community efforts on wine would be welcomed. [1] https://github.com/ValveSoftware/Proton/commit/a84120449d8177fa40f3de729e55d238d3c24877 https://github.com/ValveSoftware/Proton/commit/a84120449d817... [2] https://github.com/ValveSoftware/Proton/issues/1493#issuecomment-422022116 https://github.com/ValveSoftware/Proton/issues/1493#issuecom...
- flohofwoe 5y agoBy far most games on Windows don't run on OpenGL or Vulkan but on Direct3D. Game consoles also don't use OpenGL or Vulkan but have their own APIs. Metal is "just another" platform-specific 3D-API, it's not an exception but the norm. In reality, "cross-platform" 3D APIs don't matter much (for games). What actually matters are distribution platforms (for instance: Steam), and if a distribution platform promises good business, games will be created for it.