3 ms·
Ethernet is more costly?! Over what distance? And surely ignoring the 'endpoint hardware', switches or whatever, (or equivalently considering only stuff high en
by OJFord 5y ago
Ethernet is more costly?! Over what distance? And surely ignoring the 'endpoint hardware', switches or whatever, (or equivalently considering only stuff high enough end that it has SFP 'for free' anyway) whatever the distance?
- Sebb767 5y agoYou can get a lot of cheap, used SFP+ stuff on eBay and the likes. For short range (up to ~3m) you can go with DACs, which are 5-10€ a piece; for longer ranges, you can go to fiber, where you'll pay 20-30€ per cable. Ethernet cables are a bit cheaper, but you need high quality ones (cat6 shielded and up) and the receivers are a lot more expensive, plus they get hotter and use more power. Unless you get a really great deal on ethernet hardware or need backwards compatibility to 2.5/1 gbit, SFP+ will be a lot cheaper.
- zamadatix 5y agoIn the case of 10G sure, over any distance. Servers use cheap and simple passive copper DACs in racks and switches use optical transceivers for uplinks (usually of a higher speed RJ45 doesn't support anyways). 10G RJ45 is more complicated to implement for both the NIC and switch and requires more power, meanwhile it's not mass produced because of the aforementioned DACs and optical uplinks and lack of consumer penetration.
- icelancer 5y agoEthernet is quite a bit more costly for 10G. In our deployment we use SFP+ with 3m DACs which are downright cheap, plus long fiber runs which are more feasible and less expensive for connecting sub-sites. We support 10G-BaseT as well for devices that are 10G-PoE-BaseT but otherwise standard here is SFP+. Gets even cheaper when you consider power consumption, heat dissipation, and multi-port cards (2xSFP+ NICs are extremely affordable and nice when you have segregated networks or VM hosts). EDIT: 10G-BaseT also has ~2 orders of magnitude higher latency compared to SFP+ Fiber, and ~1 order of magnitude higher latency than SFP+ DAC. The numbers are small across the board, but it's relevant. 5-10W draw for 10GbE compared to 1-2W draw for SFP+ Fiber, for power consumption numbers.