4 ms·
As an European battling a (mild) depression I wouldn't call it a mental illness. The same goes for anxiety attacks or "alcohol dependence" (that's the first tim
by paganel 15y ago
As an European battling a (mild) depression I wouldn't call it a mental illness. The same goes for anxiety attacks or "alcohol dependence" (that's the first time when I see this mentioned as being a disease).
It's a very long explanation which I have in my head, but I don't have the mental energy to go through all of it. But parts of it would mention that any such studies that are backed up by "the director of the institute of clinical psychology and psychotherapy" are bound to be skewed on the side of "everybody is mentally ill", Michel Foucault explains it in his books better than I could ever do (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Madness_and_Civilization http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Madness_and_Civilization).
Also, I find this emphasis on "everybody should be happy and economically productive" a little bit disconcerting. Being depressed is part of being alive, you cannot just be happy from the minute you were born all the way to your dying moments. Great works (if not the greatest) of literature and of arts in general have been created by depressed people. The feeling itself of eternal, blissfully ignorant happiness makes me more depressed.
As far as "being productive all the time at all costs", I won't go into it, it isn't worth it, I just blame it on the poorly misunderstood religion of Taylorism (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frederick_Winslow_Taylor http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frederick_Winslow_Taylor)
- tuukkah 15y agoIANAP but you argue based on the fallacy that depression would be the opposite of happiness. FYI, happiness is to sadness as mania is to depression. "Alcohol dependence" is the medical term for alcoholism. There are people who drink too much, want to drink less, see their lives and loved ones destroyed by their drinking, yet they can't stop drinking. Welcome to the world of addictions. As a layman it's easy to understand someone is ill when they have bad fever or other visible, physical problems preventing them from living a normal life. It's not so easy when it's constant pain or headaches that you can't "prove". It's even less easy when it's a mental illness that you can't really even start to image unless you experience it yourself such as the anxiety attacks or the obsessive-compulsive disorder. I agree the modern society and way of life makes the problem worse by being more mentally demanding, but I'm sure there's always been mental illness. It's something that people need outside understanding and help to cope with -- just like physical illness.