4 ms·
The only way to misread the Second Amendment is to assume that it, alone among the other amendments in the original Bill of Rights, was written to constrain the
by CamperBob2 5y ago
The only way to misread the Second Amendment is to assume that it, alone among the other amendments in the original Bill of Rights, was written to constrain the people rather than the government.
In other words, you have to approach the question with an agenda -- and a conclusion -- already in mind. Bad for intellectual honesty regardless of how you feel about gun ownership rights.
- cafard 5y agoWhich government? Two states still had established churches when the First Amendment took effect.
- CamperBob2 5y agoIf the framers hadn't felt the First Amendment to be necessary, based on their awareness of both classical and all-too-recent history, they wouldn't have bothered including it. Arguably the same is true for the Second Amendment.
- nicwolff 5y agoThey didn't – Madison and Hamilton were backed into a corner during the ratification process by the anti-Federalists.
- CamperBob2 5y ago(Shrug) What ended up in the document is what counts, the rest is just commentary.
- philovivero 5y agoThis sort of sanity in interpreting written texts is disallowed on this forum. Here, guns are bad. The second amendment was meant to take away guns from the people and allow them only for the government, specifically, the armed forces. This is because here, we love tyranny, and are rather tired of the uppity flyover staters who are holding it back.
- lukas099 5y agoWho is reading the Second Amendment as constraining the people rather than the government? It seems like it is either constraining the government from restricting the private ownership and use of firearms altogether, or it is constraining the government from restricting the private ownership and use of firearms for the purpose of maintaining a militia.
- CamperBob2 5y agoWho is reading the Second Amendment as constraining the people rather than the government? Everyone who argues that the "militia" means the National Guard or another organized, government-sanctioned body.
- coolgeek 5y agoWhile the US Constitution might not strictly define militia as government-sanctioned, nearly every (if not every) state does so either in state level Constitutions or legislation. Private militias are illegal
- dragonwriter 5y ago> While the US Constitution might not strictly define militia as government-sanctioned The US Constitution presupposes a generally universal militia and US statute law explicitly defines the federal militia as consisting of all able bodied males 17-45 who are, or have made a declaration of intent to become, US citizens, plus those over 45 in or eligible to join the National Guard, plus all females in the National Guard. > Private militias are illegal Private militias are not generally illegal, but they are generally prohibited by each state from engaging in actions reserved for the state militia.