5 ms·
I'm worried we're going to find an epigenetic time bomb in destroying all senescent cells. These cells aren't just old, they remember our old life. Some adaptat
by hinkley 5y ago
I'm worried we're going to find an epigenetic time bomb in destroying all senescent cells. These cells aren't just old, they remember our old life. Some adaptations to past trauma save us from further trauma. Others are more maladaptive.
If this vaccine causes the immune system to 'forget' by killing off B cells, then you may have to get a booster shot for every vaccine you've ever had. That may not sound like a big deal but that creates a class division for longevity treatments. I could afford to take a month off, quarantine myself and get twenty booster shots. Some of my neighbors can't, so either they risk getting sick or they don't take the treatment at all.
Science fiction has always asserted there would be class divisions in these sorts of treatments, so perhaps that's not a surprise.
- codeddesign 5y agoThis is a little extreme. When was the last time you had to take a month off for a flu shot? Adults do this all the time when traveling overseas. It may be inconvenient to take a half day off to go to the clinic, but what you are saying is extreme. Not to mention, people take time off for augmentations and plastic surgery all the time.
- hinkley 5y ago> When was the last time you had to take a month off for a flu shot? A flu shot? No. If you are traveling internationally they recommend getting your vaccinations a month in advance. Plus it's generally not the case that they want you to take every vaccination on the same day. If you had to be re vaccinated for everything you're currently required to go to school, you'd be taking DTap, Polio, Varicella, MMR, Hep A, Hep B, Hib, and probably Meningitis, and a couple of those take multiple doses. > Not to mention, people take time off for augmentations and plastic surgery all the time. Everyone, or upper and middle class?
- Symmetry 5y agoIf a B cell becomes senescent it isn't going to be contributing contributing to your immune response in any event. In general a senescent cell represents a cell that failed at apoptosis when it was supposed to kill itself, going in and having the immune system finish the job won't hurt anything. That is, assuming that the vaccine works in humans and doesn't have unwanted side effects, which is very much a possibility at this stage.
- hinkley 5y agoI think that depends on utility. If the senescent cells are functionally useless, then culling them should have few consequences (although your liver and kidneys might object to having that many cells being cleaned up at once). But if they are still sort of functioning in their primary or secondary functions (eg, structural integrity) then disappearing them all at once becomes a problem.
- Symmetry 5y agoIt's true that suddenly having a whole bunch of senescent cells killed at once could cause big problems. But the number of cells that become senescent is a small fraction of the cells that manage to off themselves the way evolution intended. If this is a problem it's a problem we're continually enduring and which won't be much worsened by the drug.
- hinkley 5y agoWhen you’re 11 this is true but the whole idea with this theory of aging is that the old cells pile up, and getting some cell division rejuvenates the tissues. Cell division is controlled by feedback mechanisms based in part on intracellular pressures. That’s how your finger knows to fill in a cut. Lose some tissue, trigger division. So if you’re a tech billionaire who has noticed laugh or worry lines while checking out your hair transplants in the mirror, your body is already full of targets for this treatment. And the treatment is a vaccine. You can’t titrate a vaccine the way you can an SSRI, ramping up slowly to a full dose. Or none that I know of, so your whole body is going to be devouring itself many times faster than it normally does. You will probably develop a fever and feel weird for a moment, and your disposal systems for spare materials might be overwhelmed, like with rhabdo (mass muscle cell death leading to protein poisoning and kidney failure). I wonder if this is a case where antibodies should be administered intravenously over the course of days followed by the vaccine to make it permanent if your body handles it well.
- varelse 5y agoBefore an epigenetic time bomb detonates it's likely you will get your own very personalized cancer that will take you out unless we have come up with a universal cure-all for it. We could probably do that in a decade or two now but it would require concentrated effort. And the same mRNA technology behind the Moderna and the Pfizer vaccines might be the basis of a first generation treatment. But also it won't be cheap. At least initially. So either you'll have to have the money up front or you'll have to make a deal with someone who does and I doubt the latter ends well.
- hinkley 5y ago> it's likely you will get your own very personalized cancer that will take you out Do you mean because of the longevity treatment, or in the sense that everyone gets cancer if they live long enough?
- varelse 5y agoEveryone gets cancer if they live long enough. And cancer is subject to evolution in your own body as well as it personalizes itself to evade your immune system. It's why you can extend your lifespan but you will ultimately be foiled unless you solve the problem holistically.
- hinkley 5y agoIt seems to me than 'longevity treatments' are likely to be a quality of life situation over a quantity of life cure, changing the curve more than the intercept. A higher quality middle age has quality of life benefits that probably stand on their own, but remaining active also does increase life expectancy dramatically. So the cause-effect curve may be treatment->healthy lifestyle->life expectancy, instead of treatment->life expectancy. I could get the jab, continue to be a couch potato, and leave a prettier corpse.
- varelse 5y agoI'm intensely active and my body is great for now. But it's not going to be great forever. And I could probably afford longevity treatments to add a decade or two. But I'm disinclined to do so right now if things keep proceeding downward. Yet I will never be a couch potato. I watch less than 4 or so hours of TV weekly in an age when most watch 8 hours daily.