3 ms·
> watching the video [...] it is not clear if a human would have done any better. Anyone who's ever taken a photograph in low light conditions knows that in th
by michaelt 5y ago
> watching the video [...] it is not clear if a human would have done any better.
Anyone who's ever taken a photograph in low light conditions knows that in the dark, cameras fail to capture loads of detail that humans can make out just fine.
I'd wager a human driving in such circumstances would have seen the truck much more easily than we can see it in some dark, blurry dashcam footage.
- dragontamer 5y agoAnd as bad as it looks like on that camera, its a way better camera than the 1.2MP 1/3" CMOS sensor that Tesla uses for its "self-driving" cameras. In any case, our human eyes are actually really, really good. Far better than typical CMOS technology at capturing dynamic range and whatnot. Our Iris opens/closes depending on a variety of conditions, and our retina itself is 22 mm, far larger than typical camera CMOS sensors (but smaller than the top-of-the-line 35mm cameras). Not only is our surface-area larger... our rods / cones seem to be superior in dynamic range than CMOS technology. ---------- That being said: I think a big problem for Tesla's system is that they use tiny and cheap 1/3" CMOS sensors at low resolutions, and then expect AI to magically fix all their problems. Other companies are willing to not only buy more expensive cameras, but also more-expensive sensors, such as RADAR or LIDAR, to assist the camera.
- duskwuff 5y ago> In any case, our human eyes are actually really, really good. A dark-adapted human eye may be able to detect light levels as low as a single photon: https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms12172 https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms12172 (Not reliably, mind you. But the fact that this works at all is incredible.)