3 ms·
Posting something on the public internet is not consent for you to scrape it and post it on your own site forever. And requiring an explicit opt-in would basic
by ghaff 5y ago
Posting something on the public internet is not consent for you to scrape it and post it on your own site forever.
And requiring an explicit opt-in would basically mean no IA.
To be clear, the IA is a positive, maybe even a great one. But it skirts by because most people don't care. (They did as you say post whatever on the public internet.) Add the facts that they're a non-profit, aren't trying to monetize their hosting, and will generally take things if the owner asks.
Libraries and other archives have some very limited special rights (which mostly relate to making physical backups of physical books). But invoking "library" isn't some general get out of jail free card with respect to copyright.
- blackearl 5y agoPeople have recorded others without their consent for millennia. Whether it's telling a story about what someone said, a photo, or now a screenshot of a twitter post, that is reality. You'll never be able to stop someone from telling another that you said X.
- pessimizer 5y agoIt can be. The reason libraries and other archives have special rights is because they fought for them against the express wishes of people who sold paper. There are no arguments made against archive.org that weren't also made against libraries.
- Mezzie 5y agoThank you. These rights are also under constant attack: It's normal to charge libraries exorbitant prices for digital materials compared to their analogue counterparts, for example.
- _jal 5y ago> Posting something on the public internet is not consent for you to scrape it and post it on your own site forever. It effectively is. Your consent is not required, and people are doing far worse than just keeping it available (Clearview; there are also reports of people hoovering up encrypted data to crack in the coming decades when we're post-quantum). This is no different than demanding people not keep track of anything else, and attacking archive.org might make you feel better, but that won't make anyone else stop.
- f3rnando 5y agoI strongly believe that theres no freedom of speech without the freedom to replicate that speech.