5 ms·
Have you used these tests ? Have you read their manuals ? Of course the world is analog, it doesn't prevent me from assessing if I have socks on or not, or if m
by lm28469 5y ago
Have you used these tests ? Have you read their manuals ? Of course the world is analog, it doesn't prevent me from assessing if I have socks on or not, or if my light bulb is on or off ...
Faint lines do count, as stated in the documentation, if your eyes can see something it means it's positive, that's all there is to know, these tests have been designed to be used by humans...
- dragonwriter 5y ago> if your eyes can see something This is not a consistent standard from person to person.
- lazide 5y agoHaving used the tests multiple times (including the Ellume tests), and having Covid positive and negative results (due to a child getting it twice!! this year)? It is really hard to tell sometimes. And sometimes people don’t want to see a specific answer, and will fight over if something is positive or not. The Binax now faint line for instance can be really faint-but-still positive, and I personally got in an argument with his mom over if it counted as positive or not (day 5 and 5th positive test in a row, with decreasing line clarity each time).
- netizen-936824 5y ago>And sometimes people don’t want to see a specific answer, and will fight over if something is positive or not. This sounds like an entirely different issue. Seems like they could write off the results of the Bluetooth device readout as well if they wanted: "oh it must be faulty"
- lazide 5y agoNope - The line can be quite faint and it leaves a decent amount of room for interpretation
- netizen-936824 5y agoAs a precious comment stated "any visible line is a positive result" No ifs, ands, or buts. There is no room for interpretation according to the manufacturer instructions.
- lazide 5y agoYou clearly have not used the test in this scenario. If I could post a picture I would. Good luck!
- gruez 5y ago>Have you used these tests ? Have you read their manuals ? I don't see how personal experience plays into this. If you used it and you saw a solid line, that's not really indicative what the edge cases could be. >if I have socks on or not skin-colored stockings can be pretty hard to discern >or if my light bulb is on or off ... right, because the electrical grid is fairly stable, and light bulbs are mass manufactured with high precision. That means most of the variables that can affect brightness are removed. This can't be said for covid tests. If the light bulb was hooked up to a hand crank generator I'd have trouble figuring out whether the bulb was "on" as well. >Faint lines do count, as stated in the documentation, if your eyes can see something it means it's positive and what about lighting conditions? visual acuity? the purpose of the device is to remove variables so the test is more consistent.
- roywiggins 5y agoThe line can be very, very faint, and not everyone has better than the median eye acuity. https://twitter.com/zeynep/status/1471493781073530882 https://twitter.com/zeynep/status/1471493781073530882
- Fnoord 5y agoVery easy to see the third one is positive unless you are unwilling to or have an eye issue.
- travisporter 5y agoTrue, but the binax test for instance has clear photographed examples of what positive, F pos and erroneous tests are. I do not trust a bluetooth reader over a human interpretation - if it's ambiguous to read, we should know that, right?
- amalcon 5y agoWhy are examples useful? Is there an example of "This is the minimum that counts as positive"? What if I am unable to visually distinguish that example from a negative? If I am able to visually distinguish them, then what if there is a line but it's fainter than that minimum? You can't guarantee that both of these are impossible, because different people have different visual capabilities.
- travisporter 5y agohttps://www.fda.gov/media/144574/download https://www.fda.gov/media/144574/download page 6. It shows different gradations. That's what i'm saying, if you cannot tell the differnce in the instructions, you know not to trust the result
- roywiggins 5y agoIf the reader is calibrated and tested to be as good as a trained human with perfect eyesight, that seems better on average than relying on untrained humans with unknown eyesight. Heck, it could even be better as it would be able to supply a controlled lighting condition by measuring off a known LED.
- Zababa 5y agoMaybe that's not the case for this specific case, but consider this: https://i.redd.it/t29m67i6hch21.jpg https://i.redd.it/t29m67i6hch21.jpg. I personally can't see any number. But people tell me that there is a number here. When I use an app named "Color Blind Pal" with the "shift" function, I can see a 16. I'd like to have something that just tell me the number on the plate and not depend on my vision.