3 ms·
There is a lot of variability in numbers due to testing rates. Singapore and British Colombia have the same number of people (~5M). Singapore tested every sus
by refurb 5y ago
There is a lot of variability in numbers due to testing rates.
Singapore and British Colombia have the same number of people (~5M). Singapore tested every suspected case and only recently stopped that. They have strict measures to enter the country and have had quite strict covid restrictions (and still do!) such as no dining in, masks in all public spaces, etc.
BC had some restrictions, but no where near Singapore. Mask adoption was good but not consistent. Currently very few restrictions.
Yet Singapore reports 280,000 total cases and BC 225,000.
I’d suggest BC’s number is likely double what’s reported, if not 3x.
- hef19898 5y agoCan we have the numbers in cases per 100,000? And maybe an explanation why BC's numbers are supposed to 3x higher than what is reported?
- refurb 5y agoPopulations are comparable. And just what I said - BC had less testing, that’s why they had fewer total cases. Either that or restrictions and masks don’t work because Singapore was better than BC on both counts. They had a “circuit breaker” for a while where you couldn’t leave your house in 2020.
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoIt's easy to plot test positivity vs known cases and see how they co-relate over time. Apart from the first wave in March 2020, test positivity has tracked fairly well with case numbers here in Ontario. There's been enough testing capacity since at least Sept 2020 to track at least 4000 cases a day. And if there's significant cases being missed in testing, they'd show up in hospitalization and ICU statistics. And there's been no anomalies there. There is a group of people who really want to consider "natural immunity" as equivalent to vaccinated. But here in Canada at least the previously infected are a very small percentage of the population, at least in a way we can confirm with test results.
- hef19898 5y agoWouldn't you need percentage of positive test to draw any conclusions of the impact the number of tests has on reported cases? And the testing strategy?
- refurb 5y agoYes you would. I don’t have the energy to dig that data up or even know if it’s available, but suffice to say that Singapore would quarantine and test entire housing blocks, I’m going to guess Singapore had much more extensive testing. Singapore had effective contact tracing and at least in the beginning would do mass testing to trace each and every case. That wasn’t the case in BC.
- hef19898 5y agoGood, so it is reasonable to assume the BC underreported more then Singapore. Still quite a stretch to claim it is by a factor of three, don't you think?
- refurb 5y agoWell the 3x was entirely pulled out of my ass, so yes, it’s a stretch. But just based off the entirely different approaches I’d think BC is at least 2x it’s reported numbers? But you’re right, you could dig into number of tests, how tests were triggered, etc and come up with a much better estimate.