2 ms·
> there are a lot of aspects of math which stem from thinking, "well what if I took a square root of negative one?" I don't think that's what imaginary numbers
by thaumasiotes 5y ago
> there are a lot of aspects of math which stem from thinking, "well what if I took a square root of negative one?"
I don't think that's what imaginary numbers stem from. If I recall, they came from the much more specific question of "what if I apply the formula for roots of a cubic polynomial, even when that formula produces some nonsensical intermediate values that end up canceling each other out?".
It's less about "what if we do this?" and more about "we have this method, and it seems to work even in cases where it's not obvious that it should work".
- emj 5y agoThat is the reverse of this subject in botany, we have this method that we know works and is logical lets make our language more logical. The problem with that is the same reason we don't use imaginary numbers everywhere we can use them. Veritasium has a video description [1] with links to references about the history of imaginary numbers and polynomials. There are some great writing on this and understanding not the history but the problems that gave rise to imaginary numbers, this connection to taxonomy makes me want to read them again. There must be a study of this; failed attempts of taxonomy. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cUzklzVXJwo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cUzklzVXJwo