3 ms·
Privacy is the most obvious concern that comes to mind with apps like these, but I feel like there are potentially even bigger problems. Companies are shielded
by heavyset_go 5y ago
Privacy is the most obvious concern that comes to mind with apps like these, but I feel like there are potentially even bigger problems.
Companies are shielded from a significant amount of liability by using apps. If a company positions itself such that its mental health practitioners and patients are both users, then Section 230 of the CDA shields the app owners from almost all liability for what happens on their app. If, for example, and doctor commits malpractice or otherwise does something illegal, the company that runs the app has absolutely no legal obligation to do anything about it as they have no liability when it comes to how users use their service. This has had some pretty horrifying results in the US, and courts all the way up the the Supreme Court[1] have confirmed that, as per the CDA, operators of interactive computer services are shielded from liability for user content and actions, even if those computer services are knowingly used for fraud and assault[1].
Also, these app-based marketplaces further commodify the mental health profession. Look at any app-based marketplace or employer. Is quality what comes to mind? To me, what I see is a race to the bottom in terms of quality and compensation to sellers or workers. I think a Wish.com, but for psychiatrists, will become exactly that. Whoever owns the apps will make a lot of money, though.
[1] https://www.lawfareblog.com/herrick-v-grindr-why-section-230-communications-decency-act-must-be-fixed https://www.lawfareblog.com/herrick-v-grindr-why-section-230...