6 ms·
It used to be the case BIOS were socketed. Now, there's no socket, no header (not even the footprint for it) and of course no microcontroller-based flash metho
by snvzz 5y ago
It used to be the case BIOS were socketed.
Now, there's no socket, no header (not even the footprint for it) and of course no microcontroller-based flash method.
It would cost them literal cents to do, but they don't. It's a shame.
- RicoElectrico 5y agoThere's a connector called Tag-Connect which is actually only a PCB footprint with holes, so you get it for "free".
- mmastrac 5y agoThat is super cool. Thanks for the reference. The TTL footprint would have saved me a ton of hassle on a recent project.
- Namidairo 5y agoObviously there are generic solutions without the PCB alignment holes (and aren't patented), if you need something along those lines. Although I think clips are roughly the same price if you go that route as well.
- pantalaimon 5y agoThe Tag-Connect cable on the other hand is anything but free. I'm surprised there is no competition
- tuankiet65 5y agoYep, last time I took a look at the cable price they're pretty outrageous. I suppose they only make money on cables, not connectors - hence the markup. And it seems like the Tag-Connect is patented, which is why nobody has tried to make a clone of it?
- Gigachad 5y agoA socketed chip is hardly any easier to program when the clip works fine. It's also an extra cost added to millions of units which maybe 1-10 customers will ever actually make use of. It's just cheaper to offer a program to mail the boards in to be flashed.
- ak217 5y agoBack when BIOS chips were socketed, I once flashed the wrong BIOS onto my motherboard's chip, so it wouldn't boot. Luckily I also had an older motherboard with the same BIOS chip model. So I booted up the old one, pulled its chip out while it was running, put the new one in and flashed the new board's version - without using any special tools at all.
- snvzz 5y ago>when the clip works fine The clip is a hack. And it also does assume there's a diode to protect the board from back-feeding power, or else you have to turn on the board and do it warm, which has its own issues. When the flash chip isn't socketed, it would cost literally nothing to provide the footprint for a programming header. Just SPI on a header. That there isn't one is pretty much the middle finger to their customers. >It's also an extra cost added to millions of units which maybe 1-10 customers will ever actually make use of. It's just cheaper to offer a program to mail the boards in to be flashed. Negligible cost for just a header, even less so for a footprint. It's not about these 1-10 customers, but about local repair shops (or any friendly tech guy) being able to do this. Much better than a mailback.
- floatboth 5y agoThere are SPI headers for flashing on many many desktop mainboards.
- TedDoesntTalk 5y agoWith socketed BIOS chips, You could buy preprogrammed updates… no need to program yourself.
- fredoralive 5y agoMore expensive motherboards do have (presumably) MCU based flash tools so you can upgrade the motherboard via USB without a CPU. But this is a low end A series chipset board, it's going to be designed to be cheap, so extraneous features like that aren't going to be fitted. There probably is also some sort of "header" to allow programming Flash in the factory, but it's going to be a set of test pads that need a "bed of nails" or similar to use. I suppose you could standardise it and make it easier to field use (others mention tag-connect cables), but it's such a niche use case I'm not sure anyone would spend the time on standardising it.